Skip to search.
mythsoc · This is a list for the Mythopoeic Society, an international literary and educational organization devoted to the study, discuss

Group Information

? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Real people. Real stories. See how Yahoo! Groups impacts members worldwide.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
Early review of The Children of Hurin in The Sunday Times.   Message List  
Reply Message #17972 of 23124 |
Re: _Children of Hurin_ editions compared

Wow. Color me surprised. Thanks for letting us know, Carl.

I figured the exact opposite would be true. I'm looking at my copy of the
extended edition of Smith of Wootton Major as I write this – printed as it is on
what appears to be heavy, recycled newspaper; in fact, I think it might have
been used by a homeless person to keep the rain off before the text was printed
on it. And the binding is clogged together with the kind of glue that ... well
... let's just say, the Rohirrim wouldn't be too happy about it.

Jason

----- Carl F. Hostetter <Aelfwine@...> ----

I received my copies of both the US (Houghton Mifflin) and UK
(HarperCollins) trade editions of _Children of Húrin_ today, and
wanted to let interested readers know that while identical in
contents, the UK edition is larger in page size (also in plate size,
for the illustrations) , in better boards, on better paper, and with
better (sewn) binding. For my money, in terms of attractiveness and
durability, it's well worth the additional cost to get the UK edition
instead of the US one.

FWIW.

Carl

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]




Wed Apr 18, 2007 9:54 pm

visualweasel
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Message #17972 of 23124 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

Bryan Appleyard's review can be read here: http://entertainment.timesonline.co.uk/tol/arts_and_entertainment/book s/article1613657.ece There are no spoilers...
Merlin DeTardo
not_thou Offline Send Email
Apr 10, 2007
10:43 pm

... Drout's essay in reply to Appleyard is a delight to read. emerdavid ________________________________________ PeoplePC Online A better way to Internet ...
David Emerson
emerdavid1 Offline Send Email
Apr 11, 2007
12:02 am

... and hardly any for those who haven't. Hmm. I'm sorry, but taking another look at Appleyard's review, I realize that, almost certainly without himself...
Merlin DeTardo
not_thou Offline Send Email
Apr 11, 2007
6:25 am

... _The Silmarillion_, ... Appleyard's review, I ... realizing it, he has ... spoiler for even --or ... Middle-earth_ ... That's a pretty eenie-weenie...
William Cloud Hicklin
icelofangeln Offline Send Email
Apr 12, 2007
1:58 pm

... those who were hoping for something that was never there. Ah, but something that was never where? Appleyard's quote, and his description of it, seem to...
Merlin DeTardo
not_thou Offline Send Email
Apr 12, 2007
5:52 pm

... If you are really itching, check your local bookstores. Evidently there are a large number of stores that already have their copies up for sale. A number...
Jeremy Edmonds
rownsepyk Offline Send Email
Apr 12, 2007
6:17 pm

That will be a detail for collectors to note. Now I will be scouring bookstores here to see if there are any such "variants." HM has been sending copies out to...
Oberhelman, D
davidoberhelman Offline Send Email
Apr 12, 2007
6:23 pm

I don't think it's ever been any secret that CoH is in all essentials the Narn i Chin Hurin- augmented from other sources, perhaps, but the Narn (both as found...
William Cloud Hicklin
icelofangeln Offline Send Email
Apr 12, 2007
7:01 pm

... Aw, darn. I was hoping for a spoiler along the lines of Darth Melkor turning out to be Turin Skywalker's real father. emerdavid ...
David Emerson
emerdavid1 Offline Send Email
Apr 12, 2007
9:11 pm

... Melkor turning out to be Turin Skywalker's real father. Well, Appleyard does reference Jabba the Hut in his review....
Merlin DeTardo
not_thou Offline Send Email
Apr 12, 2007
9:58 pm

This one by Jeremy Marshall (The Ring of Words). Much better informed than Appleyard's, without being a puff piece: ...
William Cloud Hicklin
icelofangeln Offline Send Email
Apr 14, 2007
9:16 pm

The ritual "posthumous Tolkien is boring" genuflection at the start is annoying, but once you get into it it's pleasant to see that Marshall knows what he's...
David Bratman
dbratman1 Offline Send Email
Apr 15, 2007
12:53 am

Another review at the TimesOnline.com site: this one falls in the category of brutally against Tolkien. "Sentences with a gnomic brevity derived from the...
Jeremy Edmonds
rownsepyk Offline Send Email
Apr 15, 2007
4:07 pm

A much more balanced piece in The Independent: http://enjoyment.independent.co.uk/books/reviews/ article2450332.ece ... this one falls in the category of ... ...
William Cloud Hicklin
icelofangeln Offline Send Email
Apr 16, 2007
12:21 pm

I received my copies of both the US (Houghton Mifflin) and UK (HarperCollins) trade editions of _Children of Húrin_ today, and wanted to let interested...
Carl F. Hostetter
endorendil Offline Send Email
Apr 18, 2007
9:28 pm

Wow. Color me surprised. Thanks for letting us know, Carl. I figured the exact opposite would be true. I'm looking at my copy of the extended edition of Smith...
Jason Fisher
visualweasel Offline Send Email
Apr 18, 2007
9:59 pm

Hi all, I am interested in getting some back issues of the Tolkien fanzine Tyalië Tyelelliéva, run by Lisa Star but currently inactive. Her webpage has an...
Jeremy Edmonds
rownsepyk Offline Send Email
Apr 19, 2007
1:49 am

I just received the HarperCollins Deluxe _Children of Hurin_ today and really like its construction. The paper is heavy, the binding firm, the helm design on...
Oberhelman, D
davidoberhelman Offline Send Email
Apr 23, 2007
11:14 pm

... Are you sure of that? I received my copy today (I had pre-ordered it long ago but for a misunderstanding the bookshop set aside my copy and didn't send it...
Elena Rossi
rossiele Offline Send Email
May 19, 2007
5:40 pm

... Well, it may not be _that_ important, but I haven't received my copy yet, and I can tell you that like you I'll certainly be disappointed if the pages are...
hisilome Offline Send Email May 20, 2007
4:19 pm

... I too expected much better! Actually, I expected something like the edition of "the Hobbit" illustrated by Alan Lee... It's very similar as layout (both...
Elena Rossi
rossiele Offline Send Email
May 20, 2007
6:36 pm

... Well, I don't own or have seen the "Lee Hobbit", but it sounds like a nice edition! This is exactly what bothers me, there are enough examples out there of...
hisilome Offline Send Email May 21, 2007
1:45 pm

FWIW, my trade edition of CoH (obtained through Amazon) is definitely sewn....
William Cloud Hicklin
icelofangeln Offline Send Email
May 21, 2007
2:51 pm

... Yes, it is... Even the "paperback" is very solidly bound, with glossy paper and stitched binding...The only difference with the hardback is that the cover ...
Elena Rossi
rossiele Offline Send Email
May 21, 2007
4:52 pm

... This is interesting because when I got my U.S. Houghton-Mifflin copy from Amazon – I too had it preordered – I noticed it was a *second* printing. This...
Jason Fisher
visualweasel Offline Send Email
May 20, 2007
4:41 pm

I found Drout's discussion of the limitations of modernism very interesting. (He seems to be following Tom Shippey's lead here.) He also has some extremely...
lakowskir Offline Send Email Apr 12, 2007
6:55 pm

Recorded Books, Inc. also produced the Michael Drout lecture series under the title "Rings, Swords and Monsters: Exploring Fantasy Literature." Libraries...
Mattie G.
megustafson2002 Offline Send Email
Apr 13, 2007
6:15 pm
Advanced

Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines NEW - Help