Response to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/mukto-mona/message/7790

Dear Mukto-mona Friends:

As Mr Kiran A.D.H replied:

"[Sohail] :Here in USA a RSS becomes an Expatriate Indian Professional in the morning, and then becomes a VHP-America activist in the afternoon , and then becomes an HSS in the evening, and then (for around one hour ) becomes a "Liberal and Secular minded member of Mukto-mona forum" before he/she goes to bed.

[Kiran]: Well its clear that at what you are implying and you are attribution motives to me and trying to make remarks against my character(as if that is an arguement).Slinging mud at others and responding to mud is something which we all are better off to avoid. Suffice to say that I may not respond if personal accusations are made. regards,Kiran.

My Reply:

1. First of all, not even single word in my previous reply indicated that you ( Mr Kiran ) is a RSS or HSS or VHP-America activist. The real fact is that any body in this earth does have the minimum level of rights to be associated with any kind religious or political or cultural organization as long as he/she or the ORGANIZATION it self is not involved in any criminal activities such as mass murder, rape and abduction.

2. I have no idea about Mr Kiran A.D.H. I don't whether he is involved with RSS or VHP-A. The real truth is that I even don't know where he lives.

3. Had "Sangh Parivars" [ it means RSS/HSS/VHP/BJP/Bajrang/Shev Sena etc etc] been not involved in criminal activities such as mass murder, rape and riot - the issue of whether RSS is a facist organization would have never even remotely heard, right ?

4. However, there are numerous RSS/HSS/VHP-America activitists who are regular contributor of Mukto-mona forum. Here is only one of those:

 

PROFILE:

Name: Mr Utsab Chakrabarti.

Citizenship: Indian

Age: 25 ( around )

Profession: Architect

 Location: New Jersey.

Organization. An die hard activist of RSS. Presently working with RSS oversea branch in USA namely HSS. Also actively involved with VHP America.

Is also a Co-ordinator of "Human Rights Congress for Bangladeshi Minorities".

 

        2. Utsav chakrabarti ( Indian Bengali Hindu works as an architect at New Jersey )

 

            From:  utsav chakrabarti

Date:  Fri Dec 14, 2001  5:27 pm

Subject:  Re: Hindutvawadis and BD hindus

 

 govindji:

My name is utsav. Am a member of HSS.

Am in Hrcbm. Contact number is 301 459 8383 (available until

9:30 evening est from now on)..would want to talk to u about the

discussion in unitedminority list.

If u want me to contact u ..do gimme ur number.

utsav

 

 

HOWEVER, there are at least dozens of RSS/HSS/VHP activitists who are with different Bangladeshi forum with Muslim names.

with best wishes,