Response to:  http://groups.yahoo.com/group/mukto-mona/message/7778

[Sohail]

First of all, it is completely useless to urgue that there "exists" a difference between VHP and RSS while the truth is VHP, RSS, Bajrang Dal, Shev Sena, BJP etc etc ( other fanatic Hindu fundamentalists organization ) are glued together in an "umbrella" namely "Sangha Parivar" which has a clear objective to implement "HINDUTVA". All these RSS, HSS, VHP etc etc, or more accurately Slaves of Hindutva have been working hand by hand here in US and Canada to carry out the overseas agenda of Hindutva

[Kiran]

Mr.Sohail ,I was not arguing anything I mentioned facts and seeing that u have made no attempt to contradict those facts  I take it that you agree with what i have written(Including the one that mentioned  that RSS has Muslims in the organisation).I have no intention now to launch in to an argument about what RSS is about,suffice to say that the accusation that RSS is fascist is made by certain people and refuted by certain people.This ideological battle of Hindutva vs anti-Hindutva is going on in India in a democratic set up as per norms of Indian constitution.

The article that you have put here may call the judgement of Supremer court in case of Gandhis assasination as "bizarre conclusion " (it could probably lead to contempt of court in India if published from responsible publication ) and  the article might also explain away the RSS economic policy as "politically expedient move without any real will behind it as evident by what the BJP in fact did vis-à-vis the multinational Enron power project."These are just intrepretations of issues which are not simple cut and dry ones and you will surely find another plausible view.Pasting articles is an easy job and perhaps i will do it some other time to give another view.

[Sohail]

Here in USA a RSS becomes an Expatriate Indian Professional in the morning, and then becomes a VHP-America activist in the afternoon , and then becomes an HSS in the evening, and then (for around one hour ) becomes a "Liberal and Secular minded member of Mukto-mona forum" before he/she goes to bed.