WRT: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/mukto-mona/message/33033

Quote [Mankind is not for science. Science is for mankind. Man uses
science when he can afford to bear the cost of scientific tools. ]End Quote


Response: So, science and technology have done nothing for the poor, not helped
bring down the price of medicines and diagnostic tools to help them when they
were sick, not helped them get education to help them get a leg up in life. What
a wonderful observation by the world’s greatest authority on the philosophy of
science, the great Setara Hashem aka Ahamed Mohiuddin.



Quote [Therefore, the question of economy comes in. Problem of our society
is poverty. So alleviation of poverty is the main issue of our
society. Other issues which are in the periphery of the society was
called subsidiary issues. But you misunderstood it.
Promoting freethinking, science, pseudoscience, creationism,
superstition, fundamentalism and blind belief among the poor people
are mockery. Immediate need of those people is solution of their
poverty. If you think, your clienteles are educated middle class,
then still you are joking with them, because they know all these
issues, but do not open their mouth for self interest.] End Quote


Response: If alleviation of poverty is the main argument of Setra Hashem, then
I must say that Sir Isaac Newton's contribution in developing law of gravity,
Albert Einstein's contribution on developing theory of relativity, Nasa's space
research or even Tagore's literary contribution should be put into dustbin,
since those, as per Setara Hashem, did not help any poor at all. Apparently the
Setara Hashem aka Mohiuddin formula for alleviating poverty is by verbally
abusing people calling them "Bhratiya Kutta" (Indian dog), preaching DM, and
using bad grammar. Hail, the new economic formula meant to replace all other
schools of economics!



[Quote All that glitters is not gold.] End quote

Response: Setara Hashem/Mohiuddin’s posts must stink and have gold inside them
going by his blowing his own trumpet.



Quote [Views of Azizul Huq, Probir Ghosh or
Bob Avakian do not represent the policies of the main stream of
Marxist of India and USA respectively. These people do not have the
idea of reality. They are living in paradise. These people are
called utopian.] End quote


Response: Setara Hashem/Mohiuddin, a self appointed intellectual giant of a man
who cannot afford to write under his own name but must use a feminine pseudonym
has decreed that these thinkers are “living in paradise.” Shades of your
religious goggles, Mohiuddin? Off with their heads?



Quote [You mentioned about Shatidaha and Copernicus/Galileo etc. Every
thing depends on time, place and condition, is the rule of logic. I
think you forgot that rule of logic. My next article, which will be
posted in 2nd week of next month, will be dealt with how your views
are violating the rules of logic. Please wait for that time.] End Quote

Response: What a revelation the world is due to receive! Hail the next prophet,
a potential Nobel winner for his expertise in logic and a writer in pathetic
grammar! Everybody please stand to attention and salute!

Mehul Kamdar