Dear Mr. Md. Mahmoodul Haque,

I am reading your articles with special attention. You seem to have vast
knowledge especially on science and religion. I have a few query. I would
request you to explain with logic and necessary references.


Regarding the first revelation to Prophet Muhammad (S): After getting first
revelation Prophet Muhammad (S) HIMSELF did not know what really happened to
him. He then went back home and informed the event to his wife Khadija. Then
Khadija took him to her cousin Warraq Naufal and told him what happened to
Prophet Muhammad (S). Warraq Naufal (a Jews converted to Christianity)
confirmed him that it was a revelation. I have a few questions on it:

1. How come Prophet Muhammad (S) HIMSELF didn't know that it was a
revelation to him?
2. How did Warraq Naufal confirmed him that it was a revelation?
3. Warraq Naufal just inferred it based on the then religious book, right.
4. Now the thing is as Naufal said and thats why it was considered as
revelation (maybe it was not).
5. Or what if Naufal would say that it was not a revelation (but actually it
was), would it not be considered as revelation?
6. That means, it was completely depending upon what Naufal said, right.
7. If Naufal was so sure that it was really a revelation he should have been
the first converted. But there is no reference that Naufal was converted or
just wanted to be.

What would you say if I say that Islam is just standing on the word of
Warraq Naufal?


8. In what circumstance(s) Allah Taala told Prophet Muhammad (S) that the
then religious scripture needs to be changed, I mean there needs another
scripture? Did Allah Taala really told him anyway?

9. What were the wrongs with Bible so that Allah Taala decided to send
Quran? Why Allah Taala did not promise to save Torah and Bible from
corruption as He has promised in Quran? Was it a wrong from his side?


Regarding Satan:

Who created Satan/Evil-Nafs? If not Allah, then Satan is either self created
or another God has created him. Then Allah is not all in all. If Allah
created him, then what we hear/know regarding Satan is just riddiculous.
Whatever good/bad things are happening in the universe is the cause of Allah
then. What is your comment on this.


Thanking you.
MRS

_________________________________________________________________
MSN 8 with e-mail virus protection service: 2 months FREE*
http://join.msn.com/?page=features/virus




*********************************************
*** New petition from Mukto-mona:
Initiate Bilateral Talks for the River Interlinking Project :
  
http://www.mukto-mona.com/human_rights/river_link/index.htm
*********************************************

Save the Minorities from peril and let live with equal rights:
  
http://www.mukto-mona.com/human_rights/petition_peace/

*********************************************

Mukto-mona is a cyber discussion forum that encourages freethinking, humanism and rationalism among the members. It, also, appears as an action group. Mukto-mona members raised their voice against many unjust acts around the globe.

You can read our mails at http://www.mukto-mona.com/Forum/forum.html

VISIT MUKTO-MONA WEB-SITE : http://www.mukto-mona.com/


****************************************************

"I may disagree of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it."

-Voltaire

*****************************************