RE: [mukto-mona] For MC: When Almighty Allah Does Not Know
Here I want to give emphasis on the observation of Mr. Imran Hossain. As he wrote: "A God can NOT send godly message like "Guide ‘us’ in the straight path." Mr. Hossain has made a good observation. It is contradictory to the concept of the Almighty where He Himself is saying to guide "us." This "Guide Us" prayer should be from the followers of Allah. Here it appears that Allah is praying to Himself. How logical it is! Is He teaching His followers how to pray to Him? If it were so, then He could have mentioned it at the beginning of the first Sura (chapter) of Quran. But, there is no such indication. How could an All-Knowing Almighty make silly mistake like this? In fact, the whole Sura (Fateha) is a type of prayer that begins with Praise for Allah. Is Allah praising Him and at the same time praying to Himself? I expect a clarification from
Mr. Mohammad Choudhury, who is trying hard to defend his faith.
Thank you very much for writing to me. I really appreciate that you answered at least some of my questions. Let’s go back to the discussion.
My reply to some of the questions:
1) "Now please tell me what this “guidance” is or"..................The guidance is for the people who believe and their asking of the "straight Path" as in Surah Fatiha: "Guide us in the straight path"...............Which leads to eternal success i.e. "Salvation in the Hereafter, the eternal life after the little transitory life and death."................
My dear MC, I have to add some other information to answer this. Therefore, I want to make sure that you trust Koran is a book of true words of almighty God i.e. your Allah. If you believe that, sir, you are dead wrong in your first response. A God can NOT send godly message like "Guide ‘us’ in the straight path."
Mohammad Choudhury@... wrote:
My reply to some of the questions:
1) "Now please tell me what this “guidance” is for"..................The guidance is for the people who believe and their asking of the "straight Path" as in Surah Fatiha: "Guide us in the straight path". ..............Which leads to eternal success i.e. "Salvation in the Hereafter, the eternal life after the little transitory life and death."................
[Moderator note : Macroevolutionists at Wayne State University School of Medicine in Detroit announced key genetic material (DNA) of people and chimps that is...
Here I want to give emphasis on the observation of Mr. Imran Hossain. As he wrote: "A God can NOT send godly message like "Guide ‘us’ in the straight...
Shabbir Ahmed
Feb 9, 2004 5:11 am
'Value-based education can eliminate corruption' By Manas Dasgupta GANDHINAGAR, FEB. 8. The President, A.P.J. Abdul Kalam, today had a dig at the multiplicity...
Feb 8, 7:49 PM EST American Airlines Pilot Plugs Christianity NEW YORK (AP) -- An American Airlines pilot asked Christians on his flight to identify themselves...
The Atlantic Monthly | December 2003 The Bubble of American Supremacy A prominent financier argues that the heedless assertion of American power in the world...
KHAN MAIMUL
Feb 10, 2004 3:53 am
... _________________________________________________________________ Check out the great features of the new MSN 9 Dial-up, with the MSN Dial-up Accelerator....
KHAN MAIMUL
Feb 10, 2004 3:54 am
Foreigners work longer, get less in Gulf ‘Guests’ who toil in oil-rich states live under harsh conditions Abbas Salman MANAMA: Niran, a 45-year-old...
KHAN MAIMUL
Feb 10, 2004 3:57 am
Dear Friends: In this open letter addressed to Presiden Bush, Senator Kerry and the other Democratic aspirants to the presidency, B Raman, one of the world's...
Dear Moderator, Thanks for the useful link you enclosed. That is a nice article, but author mentioned only few verses. In fact, there are hundreds of words in...
Imran Hossain
Feb 10, 2004 4:06 am
Dear Shabbir Ahmed, You said "How could an All-Knowing Almighty make silly mistake like this?" Yes I am also confused regarding this. I have given a little...
In Quran it's so apparent and explicit that it's Muhammaed himself and not any so called Allah who is speaking to us, yet most Muslims believe otherwise. Same...
I totally agree with both Shabbir's comments and very sharp observation of Imran (a boy of only 21). I am amazed how a young boy like Imran can see a clear...
Syed Kamran Mirza
Feb 10, 2004 4:10 am
Is there anybody please explain how and why these miracles should not be considered as a series of claimed miracles of quran? Has sombody already explained...
... (1) The laws of Physics are just that..the laws of physics. They just tell us "HOW" of the interactions. ... (2) Again, there is no such things as...
... I used the expression "either God or to LIFE" because I wanted to respond to another post in this forum - which claimed that law of physics proves...
Decide on merit, rules SC SC, ST benefits to converted Christians S S Negi Legal Correspondent New Delhi, February 8 The Supreme Court in an important ruling...
An Introduction to Real Islam and Jihad (Part 13/15) [Readers, please note: the original author of this ‘Book’ sent me the draft for a review and...
Abul Kasem
Feb 10, 2004 4:25 am
Due to our relentless 'pen pushing' we now observe a new breed of Hadith-less and Sharia-less Muslims. Obviously these are the greatest of all hypocrites. They...
Abul Kasem
Feb 10, 2004 4:25 am
This is an illuminating article; I hope you and others would enjoy reading it. Mohammad Asghar Sharia Laws -- Heavy Deception With Abusive Divinity The dogmas...
Mohammad Asghar
Feb 10, 2004 4:25 am
[Moderator note : After the Dec.6,1992 incident in Ayodhya, India (destruction of the disputed Babri mosque) Anti-Hindu forces in the rest of the world reacted...
Dr. Ajoy Roy
Feb 10, 2004 4:52 am
In response to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/mukto-mona/message/15029 Adnan I was unable to open any of the miracles at the web site you mentioned. Can you...
In response to: "Ann Druyan Talks About Science, Religion, Wonder, Awe...and Carl Sagan": http://www.mukto-mona.com/news/ Dear All, I read the article by Ann...
arijit biswas
Feb 10, 2004 11:03 am
Tehelka / Edit one/lead article/feb 14 If Gods become silent The speechless must speak Dalits are rejecting Hinduism. Why make a song and dance about it? asks...
buddha mail
Feb 11, 2004 4:29 am
A DAILY MEDIA MONITOR OF RIGHTS VIOLATIONS IN INDIA. INDIA: RIGHTS & WRONGS SATURDAY 07 JANUARY 2004 RELIGIOUS FREEDOM/ COMMUNALISM Out of job after riot,...
Sabrang
Feb 11, 2004 4:30 am
It would be really difficult to understand for someone who does not believe in some kind of deity, the Creator of Everything, the Almighty God, the Most ...
Mohammad Choudhury
Feb 11, 2004 4:32 am
Does anyone know what religion the people of Afghanistan follow. Let me tell you they follow the islamic religion. We have seen it in Iraq after the coalition...
We need to remind ourselves of some overlooked realities here: 1) Afghanistan and parts of Iran have been growing afeem for centuries, it's part of the...
India's eastern neighbour Bangladesh sent 545 students to study here while Ethiopia, where a large number of Indians teach at school level, had 281 students...
KHAN MAIMUL
Feb 11, 2004 4:42 am
A DAILY MEDIA MONITOR OF RIGHTS VIOLATIONS IN INDIA. INDIA: RIGHTS & WRONGS TUESDAY 10 JANUARY 2004 RELIGIOUS FREEDOM/ COMMUNALISM 'Move for reforms among...
Having problems with message search?
Send Email
