Reply to MC on When Almighty Allah Does Not Know

By Imran Hossain

imranhossainbd@...

12 January 2004

 

Dear Mohammad Choudhury,

 

I’d like to thank you first for your attempt to write to me. The verses you quoted I’ve read them lots of times. I am now going to attack your message, not you for sure. Blue ones with quotations are yours.

 

“If you have read Quran and understood its meaning such FAQ's would not have come to your mind.”

Before going to the main topic, I need to know from you a little question: Dear MC, did you accept Islam after understanding Holy Koran’s meaning?

 

According to your claim and Koran

 

“The Quran gives guidance to those who are: Read verses 2:2-5.”

These verses tell us those who have faith in almighty Allah; they have the “guidance” from Allah. [These are summary]

“It will not give guidance who are: Read verses 2:6-7.”

These verses tell us those who have do NOT believe in almighty Allah, they have NO the “guidance”. [These are summary]

“The third category of people are: Read verses 2:8-16. So compare yourself with these three categories as each and every human being would fall in one of such categories which Allah (SWT)has categorised.” And   “there is no doubt about it. Just compare and you would find each and every person to be in one of these groups of human biengs.”

You are right on it. Here Allah also says on those verses the punishment is ready for them. [These are summary]

 

 

My reply to you:

 

Now please tell me what this “guidance” is for. Those who believe in Allah why they CAN NOT handle the “guidance”? But those who do NOT have any faith in Allah how they handle the “guidance”? How Kaffirs discover: the earth is round, no air up the sky, North and South America, cloning and test tube baby etc which I claimed. Do Kaffirs have faith in Allah? Where is Allah’s “guidance” here”?

 

Mr MC: could you please tell me why I need to know the third category of people and compare them to one another in order to figure out my FAQ’s? Whether they go to hell or heaven, so what, but are these people solving my questions which I wrote?

 

The verses from 2 to 16 of Sura Al Baqra  and even from the whole Koran are TOTALLY irrelevant and incorrect to my claims I made.

 

Why don’t you try to show the verses from 2 to 16 of Sura Al Baqra or from whole Holy Koran to a matured non-Muslim guy and tell him to believe my FAQ’s which Allah solved them in His book?

 

- - - - - - -

Please keep on contributing your write-up in Mukto-Mona.

Have a good day.

 

 
Mohammad Choudhury@... wrote:

See some replies of your questions below.

If you have read Quran and understood its meaning such FAQ's would not have
come to your mind. The Quran gives guidance to those who are: Read verses
2:2-5. It will not give guidance who are: Read verses 2:6-7. Whether they
are warned or not they will not believe. The third category of people are:
Read verses 2:8-16. So compare yourself with these three categories as each
and every human being would fall in one of such categories which Allah (SWT)
has categorised. There is no doubt about it. Just compare and you would find
each and every person to be in one of these groups of human biengs.

Now read some answers under your questions:

---

Post your free ad now! Yahoo! Canada Personals


*********************************************
*** New petition from Mukto-mona:
Initiate Bilateral Talks for the River Interlinking Project :
  
http://www.mukto-mona.com/human_rights/river_link/index.htm
*********************************************

Save the Minorities from peril and let live with equal rights:
  
http://www.mukto-mona.com/human_rights/petition_peace/

*********************************************

Mukto-mona is a cyber discussion forum that encourages freethinking, humanism and rationalism among the members. It, also, appears as an action group. Mukto-mona members raised their voice against many unjust acts around the globe.

You can read our mails at http://www.mukto-mona.com/Forum/forum.html

VISIT MUKTO-MONA WEB-SITE : http://www.mukto-mona.com/


****************************************************

"I may disagree of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it."

-Voltaire

*****************************************

---

Yahoo! Groups Links

• To visit your group on the web, go to:
  http://groups.yahoo.com/group/mukto-mona/
   
• To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
  mukto-mona-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com
   
• Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service.