Hello Larry, Hello all ! I swap all arguments adressing with PGH content to another thread (PGH and Lk 1.5-7). Here remain methodology topics. I would like to...
2378
Emmanuel.Fritsch@...
Jun 1, 2001 5:35 pm
PGH and Lk 1.5-7, Lk 1,18 : I give here a sumary of Boismard arguments on this verses. the reference is the book on birth narrative, pp 66-68
* Lk 1-5 is...
2379
Emmanuel.Fritsch@...
Jun 1, 2001 5:38 pm
# Boismard has tended to ignore facts, or overlook them, or # look at them from only a particular point of view. As such, # his arguments regarding the...
2380
Jim
brewspad@...
Jun 1, 2001 5:40 pm
Thank you Yuri. Jim Brewster Kent Washington brewspad@......
2381
Emmanuel.Fritsch@...
Jun 1, 2001 5:54 pm
# # Thank you Yuri. # Yes, that is great. a+ manu...
2382
Yuri Kuchinsky
yuku@...
Jun 1, 2001 8:18 pm
On Mon, 28 May 2001 Emmanuel.Fritsch@... wrote: [Yuri:] ... Manu, This example is important only in so far as it shows clearly how wrong Petersen's...
2383
Yuri Kuchinsky
yuku@...
Jun 1, 2001 8:32 pm
... Jim, I have no idea if verse 23 above is a later expansion, or a primitive passage that was edited out later by the canonicals. Arguments could be easily...
2384
Yuri Kuchinsky
yuku@...
Jun 1, 2001 9:28 pm
... [Jim:] ... Jim, And then again, Ignatius, assuming it's spurious, could have been based on Mt. ... I'm saying that none of the canonicals is early, and...
2385
Yuri Kuchinsky
yuku@...
Jun 1, 2001 10:04 pm
Dear friends, In the beginning of this post, there's some info about Son of Man (SOM) title in general, and later there's some info specifically relating to ...
2386
Kanefer@...
Jun 1, 2001 10:29 pm
from PGH 23 And Jesus replied, and asked him to do it, for it was very proper for them to do so [for the sake of] giving all others a [good] example in every...
2387
Yuri Kuchinsky
yuku@...
Jun 2, 2001 5:41 pm
Dear friends, As I have now discovered, there were a couple of errors in my SOM post of yesterday, so, before proceeding to other stuff, I would like to...
2388
Jim Deardorff
deardorj@...
Jun 2, 2001 6:35 pm
... Yuri, Doesn't the fact that HMt lacks some of Matthew's SOMs, but *contains many more*, indicate to you that it is simple enough for an editor to remove ...
2389
Jim Deardorff
deardorj@...
Jun 2, 2001 6:35 pm
... That has been the typical view. But it fails to explain why most of those parallels aren't closer in wording, why Ignatius's epistles (short form) didn't...
2390
Jeffrey B. Gibson
jgibson000@...
Jun 3, 2001 9:12 pm
Yuri, I wonder if you'd give the List your opinion on the value of the Curetonian Syriac as a witness to the original text of the canonicals? Thanks, JG -- ...
2391
Larry J. Swain
l9swain@...
Jun 4, 2001 5:11 am
Manu wrote: PGH and Lk 1.5-7, Lk 1,18 : I give here a sumary of Boismard arguments on this verses. the reference is the book on birth narrative, pp 66- 68 * Lk...
2392
Larry J. Swain
l9swain@...
Jun 4, 2001 5:15 am
Regarding the nature of the PGH harmony: [Manu:] ... gospels. It either ... parallel columns, one ... older type is the ... gospels into a single ... all four...
2393
Kanefer@...
Jun 4, 2001 11:33 am
I wonder if the story of Hannah offers a clue then - showing two wives, and the priest sympathizing with Hannah's plea & telling her the Lord had granted her...
2394
Kanefer@...
Jun 4, 2001 11:41 am
... Jeffrey wrote: <<Yuri, I wonder if you'd give the List your opinion on the value of the Curetonian Syriac as a witness to the original text of the...
2395
Yuri Kuchinsky
yuku@...
Jun 4, 2001 4:16 pm
On Fri, 1 Jun 2001, Larry J. Swain wrote: [Yuri:] ... What is this supposed to mean? Larry's syntax seems to be more convoluted than usual. So why did Petersen...
2396
Yuri Kuchinsky
yuku@...
Jun 4, 2001 4:28 pm
On Fri, 1 Jun 2001, Larry J. Swain wrote: [Yuri:] ... Nope. I and Quispel in fact agree on the relationships of the Western tradition. The one who disagrees...
2397
Yuri Kuchinsky
yuku@...
Jun 4, 2001 4:39 pm
... This is obviously false. ... Such minor glosses are very obvious, and they comprise only about 1% of PG text. So I just wonder why do you wish to focus on...
2398
Yuri Kuchinsky
yuku@...
Jun 4, 2001 4:49 pm
... But I don't think Boismard needs an excuse on this one. Rather it is you who's still begging the question. Because you have not actually demonstrated that...
2399
Yuri Kuchinsky
yuku@...
Jun 4, 2001 5:03 pm
... But Eusebius has a clear anti-Jewish-Christian agenda. So why do you want to buy into it? ... I don't think so. ... There certainly was. But you may have...
2400
Yuri Kuchinsky
yuku@...
Jun 4, 2001 5:49 pm
... I'm not quite sure, Jeffrey, why are you now focusing on the Curetonian Syriac as opposed to on the older Sinaiticus Syriac, which also seems to preserve a...
2401
Larry J. Swain
l9swain@...
Jun 5, 2001 5:49 am
Manu wrote: # Manu now responds: # What I wanted to say : it is improductive to discuss about "direct" # or "indirect". These are just words. The main issue...
2402
Larry J. Swain
l9swain@...
Jun 5, 2001 5:55 am
... wives, and ... had granted ... petition ... bear a ... Samuel? ... Patti, I think you've confused something here. Eli does not tell her that her request...
2403
Kanefer@...
Jun 5, 2001 2:07 pm
Larry wrote: <<Patti, I think you've confused something here. Eli does not tell her that her request was granted, but merely says (after making the gross...
2404
Jim Deardorff
deardorj@...
Jun 5, 2001 3:53 pm
... for ... in ... is ... man ... virtue." ... being ... after ... killed ... over ... following ... Patti, I think you are just noticing some of the evidence...
2405
Robert Raphael
rraphael3@...
Jun 6, 2001 4:04 am
I was wondering if anyone has any idea as to whether it is possible that Jewish Philosopher Philo of Alexandria influenced the content of the Gospel of John. I...
2406
Larry J. Swain
l9swain@...
Jun 6, 2001 5:59 am
... omitted> this citation from the second edition. Actually, it _is_ in the second> edition. And the reason why I made this mistake is because of William L.>...
