Hi Goetz, After attempting to decipher your message, here, after a very "careless reading" is what I get: 1) you don't own up to misquoting me - even after I...
... With regard to our whole dialogue on this matter it isn't such a good idea that you are the one who complains about going to ad hominem. So let's return to...
I hate to spoil the party, but for the sake of what I and my references believe is literary correctness and albiet controversial record keeping, it was Alice...
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/lewiscarroll/photos/album/1201996902/pic/list is a collection of some of Henry Holiday's illustrations to Lewis Carroll's "The...
As far as I can tell, this is one of the flimsiest things I've seen. As I predicted some time ago, if we were to follow you way of doing things, everything...
Ad rem. We take http://www.snrk.de/HolidayGheeraertsFiltered.jpg as an example. Hypothesis: Henry Holiday quoted in his illustration (left picture) from that ...
... There is no probability that the hypothesis is true, in my opinion, and frankly I am very, very bored with being asked to look at this picture over and...
I agree with Michael: your presentation of the same pictures over and over again does not prove anything other than your idea (fixe?) that they are connected. ...
Fernando, I assume you enjoy engaging in this quasi-debate with Goetz. If I'm wrong in that, why not just ignore him? My suspicion is that he enjoys winding...
peter wesley-smith
peterws@...
Nov 8, 2009 10:22 pm
15697
Hi Fernando, Thank you. That's all I wanted to hear from you. Goetz...
Hi Peter, I would ignore him if I knew that he (and Robert B.) wasn't confusing new comers to LC studies. Because he posts as though his stuff was regular...
Hi Deb, Thank you for the information. I have ordered this book and I will see how Page handled the very complicate narrative in Phantastes. If you read...
I hate to see my party spoiled. I joined this group a few years ago because I was re-reading a couple of CLD's biogs in conjunction with Karoline's book, and...
... Action could be taken. ... I feel much the same. Except that I do have administrative powers. ... Well. There's the nonsense.... Seriously, I have...
Re-posting. Evertype is delighted to announce the publication of a new set of Alice stories, by Keith Sheppard of Berkshire. "Wonderland Revisited and the...
... Hi Michael, Just to let you know, I am one of those people who are considering to quit the list, of which I think I have been a member for over 10 years. I...
I apologise in advance to those who have expressed a dislike for self promotion on this group. Please be advised that I don't intend to make a habit of it but...
... I don't believe that announcement and discussion of new books is "self promotion". I mean, it is, but I don't think it's out of bounds or unacceptable. ...
Michael, I move my elswhere deleted "good bye" to this response. If you deal with ICD-10 terms, you should know that psychatric diagnoses made in public...
Fernando, I have been working on LCD's symbolic logic. In your researches of his writings or anything about him have you come across references to "objects"...
Were nt these two guys living parallel lives ? both went to Oxford as students, both later lectured at Oxford both deeply interested in art and artists both...
Hi Mitch, I think I have read all of MacDonald's books and I don't remember seeing these Carrollian types of references. I made note of anything that struck...
I don't know what you are talking about; something about psychoanalysis.Are you offended that I supposed Alice might have been rude? Well, maybe it was the...
Thanks, Fernando, i am somewhat of a novice in Carroll-ania since my primary background and interest is the use of Boolean techniques for solving his logic...
Hi Mitch, I will keep my eye out for that. You have probably thought of this, but once we look at how Logic was understood in the 19th Century we quickly find...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
