Dear Hegel Group, I had the privilege of attending the Hegel Conference in New York. There were many presentations read and discussed, among which was a most...
robertfanelli002@...
Apr 4, 2004 9:32 pm
2363
Robert, Professor MacDonald is correct to emphasize that Hegel's science of logic overcomes Kant's challenges to any future metaphysics. Hegel's Logic shows...
Dear all, First of all, thank you to Robert Fanelli for publicly raising an issue that I develop at length in the paper he mentions, which I gave at the...
... What does Iain Macdonald mean with "an attitude of logical optimism in respect of anything that presents itself as resistant to reason"? Hegel only wants...
Dear all, A little hermeneutic generosity often goes a long way. That said, I believe my presentation of the passage I quote from the greater Logic is faithful...
... I do not understand this, but applied to Hegel's philosophy I fully agree. ... It is very important to understand that the Concept releases its other from...
Dear Randall, 1. It is indeed true that a proper understanding of sense-certainty requires its placing within the general context and aim of the Phenomenology...
Let's review that quotation cited by Professor MacDonald that started this exchange. It's on page 826 of the Miller translation of Hegel's SCIENCE OF LOGIC...
**DOCUMENT 3: THE TASK OF THE PHENOMENOLOGY MUST BE TRANSCENDENTAL** 1. THERE IS NO NEED FOR EXPLICIT SELF-KNOWLEDGE: As we have tried to show, [1] Hegel is...
**DOCUMENT 1: EXTERNAL CHARACTERIZATION OF SENSE-CERTAINTY [PARA 90 - 93] ** 1. THE BEGINNING OF THE INVESTIGATION OF CONSCIOUSNESS: The knowledge, which is...
DOCUMENT 2: THE RELATION BETWEEN THE LOGIC & THE PHENOMENOLOGY 1. But thus far such an explication still must ask about the *terms* with which Hegel can...
Dear Ioannis Trisokkas, It is clear from the quotations you submitted this week from Howard Kainz and Robert Pippin that Howard Kainz is one of the most lucid...
Dear Ioannis, Just a note to express my appreciation for your contributions. I was unaware of Pippin's 1975 work. Truthfully, I had given up on pursuing an...
Dear Folks, I am pleased to inform you that I have a new On Line Service. It is robertfanelli@... I am sending it to you on my old On Line Service...
robertfanelli002@...
Apr 12, 2004 8:49 pm
2376
Hi, Hope you like your new service! -- Peter G. Stillman Director, Program in Environmental Studies (845-437-5430) Professor, Department of Political Science...
Dear list, Please take a look at the outline I have constructed for the chapter on Perception in the PHENOMENOLOGY OF SPIRIT. II. Perception Even though the...
Dear List, Bob Fanelli asked his friends to respond to his NEW email address, and NOT to the Yahoo List. Please do not respond to Bob by replying to Yahoo....
On Thu, 11 Mar 2004 20:23:39 -0500, Ralph Dumain wrote: <snipped stuff irrelevant to Hegel philosophy maillinglist> ... One of the books I read early on in my...
Gerald Somerville
gerald.somerville@...
Apr 16, 2004 5:52 pm
2380
Maybe on day I will explain my in-joke. Just a comment or two below. ... Further caveats: (1) I know little of Fackenheim, except for a primer on Judaism for...
... I almost agree, Gerald. Fackenheim is mostly fair in his reporting of Hegel -- remember Fackenheim was a post-WW2 Jewish scholar. Hegel was arguably one...
... This snippet fails to connect Feuerbach's views with Hegel's, though. ... This is all a lie. ... Yes, Marx did repeat some of these nasty views about Jews...
... determined with scrupulous rigor. -- ... your man. I cannot see how Hegel's "actual views" can be anything other than what he said or wrote. Among the...
Sorry. The ending sentence in my post should in fact be read: << In Hegelian terms, one might be led to conclude that the 'truth' of Dumain's position about...
This is all contrived bullshit. I have no agenda as far as the Trejo-Greuter debate is concerned, none. I just want to make sure I am reading the argument...
Dear Ralph, ... Don't worry, I agree. What I wrote is probably false. A problem with you guys coming from a British/American (whatever) background is that you...
... Oh, for goodness sake, Ralph, are you hiding your head in the sand? That book is FAMOUS. It's all over the Internet. Did you think I would make up...
But is it true that the Italian who was murdered by terrorists actually said something along the lines of - 'now you will see that Italians know how to die...
Below is an extract from Gerald's recent post, where, seemingly out of the blue, he brings up Hegel's philosophy of nature. And, actually, I don't understand...
... Do you mean that the negation of all progressive moments in Hegel's philosophy as positive attributes of Hegel's philosophy itself does lead to a...
I think Beat is using the word 'dogmatism' with two different meanings below. On the one hand to be dogmatic is to have a very rude and unpleasant manner. This...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
