Hi Michael, Hegel's section on Civil Society in his PHILOSOPHY OF RIGHT (1812) is so rich in concepts that Professor David MacGregor suggests Marx closely...
Paul Trejo
petrejo@...
Dec 13, 2002 12:43 am
29
i am attempting to compare marx's theory of class in his economic writings to that of hegel in philosophy of right... could anyone shed some light on this...
Dear All, I propose that you stop just for a minute to get involved with Bauer, Marx, Kojève, the Philosophy of Right and so on, to commemorate the 171st ...
Maurizio Canfora
maurizio.canfora@...
Nov 14, 2002 7:50 am
27
... From: Ralph Dumain [mailto:rdumain@...] Sent: Dienstag, 5. November 2002 05:36 To: hegelnet@yahoogroups.com Subject: Re: [hegelnet] I will forego the...
I would like to bring in several matters raised by José Crisóstomo de Souza on the Hegel-Hegelians forum. They are sumed up in the two quotes below from two...
Stephen thanks for this posting. I am very sure there is no reference to Hegel within the Origin, and that Darwin ideas developed very empirically (at least...
Dear Greg, There is a recent book on the Wedgewood group, entitled "The Lunar Men" (2002) by Jenny Uglow. I understood that Charles Darwin's theory of ...
Stephen Cowley
Stephen@...
Nov 2, 2002 9:38 am
23
Ivor, I have no problem with what you say below at all - it is a timely correction. Well might Darwin have echoed Marx's response to having ideas associated...
In the discussion of anti-semitism and Darwin, Greg and then Kai make the ... generational ... ideologies ... was ... I am not sure that Darwin can take the...
Ivor Sarakinsky
Machiavelli@...
Nov 1, 2002 12:31 pm
21
Paul one more thing I missed in the previous post, you say: "That is not enough to explain Marx's many (not a few, but many) anti-Semitic writings." I am at...
Paul, there are now an obvious number of areas of broad agreement and a narrowing down to specific relations between his philosophy and antisemticism. I am...
... Greg, it seems to me that you're minimizing Marx's lapse of wits. Is anti-Semitism only of interest to contemporary political correctness? I don't think...
Paul Trejo
petrejo@...
Nov 1, 2002 3:54 am
18
Paul I really don't think that Marx's antisemetic remarks are being trivialized by anyone. Assessing their importance in view of his theoretical work which...
Stephen, Yes, we can agree with all the five points you laid down there, but with a twist. How can anybody minimize anti-Semitism? It surprises me when I see...
Paul Trejo
petrejo@...
Oct 31, 2002 11:14 pm
16
Dear Paul, I've just had a chance to read this thread. I think we owe it to all concerned to be clear about the facts here. I agree with Kai that it's not ...
Stephen Cowley
Stephen@...
Oct 31, 2002 7:26 pm
15
Dear Greg, ... leave ... Ok, than I will not make it a priority. However, in case I ever get the CD-ROM (it costs some 125 EUR) I hope I will think of you and...
Thank you Peter ever so much for me this clears up a lot and makes things even more interesting, I should go through the article again and substiting ever...
Paul, your recent post clarifies much and shows that no great problem exists (your views on Marx's anti-semticism aside). However there are some small points...
... Dear Greg and Kai, According Shlomo Avineri in an article on Marx and Jewish Emanicipation in the Journal of the History of Ideas, probably in the mid...
Peter G. Stillman
Stillman@...
Oct 31, 2002 2:05 am
11
... First, Dr. Stillman, I want to say what an honor it is to hear from you on the Hegel-Marx List. Your years of contributions to Hegel studies in the area...
Paul Trejo
petrejo@...
Oct 30, 2002 11:50 pm
10
Kai thanks for this but please do not bother yourself on my account, I could be very wrong on this use of language and trying to find evidence is either very...
Dear Greg, it seems we do agree on that Marx text. ... to ... Unfortunately, fullfilling this request may take some time. I am a native speaker of todays...
Thanks Kai for this posting below, as I know no German I have to rely on the the English translation. The phrase in English which I thought might have been...
... whether it is ... Trhe German text can be found in several places in the net, e.g. at http://www.mlwerke.de/me/me01/me01_347.htm According to that source,...
Please excuse this reposting to this list. It began as a posting by Paul Trejo in the Hegel-Hegelians and if anywhere it should be here. It is rather long and...
Paul, first how nice to see you in this forum, a place which I feel more at home (standing on Marx peering back at Hegel). Strangely the subject you raise...
... case. I am not sure how much it matters, either to Marx or to Hegel, to pull quotations like these out of context and oppose them. But the obvious...
Peter G. Stillman
Stillman@...
Oct 29, 2002 6:58 pm
3
Hi Paul, ... First some first impressions, how one could understand this (just out of my head, we could easily find more with some time spent): a) As you say...
Dear List, Marx contradicted himself, I believe, when he said the following two sentences. The first was near the beginning of his career, the second was...
Paul Trejo
petrejo@...
Oct 29, 2002 5:55 pm
1
I am new to these listings and have limited knowledge of Hegel (which must be improved). I will not therefore make any grand statements about the connection...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
