Here's an open invitation to participate in an active, eclectic and commercial-free philosophy forum. It's worth a peek. http://members2.boardhost.com/wbaker2/...
The London reading group looking at Marx's Early Writings will be meeting during the summer term on alternate Wednesdays in room D108, 1st floor, Social...
Hi Andy D, That's not much reading from Hegel, is it? (only 1 chapter) Most (or at least many) Marxists would agree that the best way to understand Marx is by...
Hope this is not too idiotic of a query but would anyone be recording this or taking minutes? Can't make it. A bit of a ride from Brussels. Thanks, -Jon...
jonathan yegge
jyegge@...
May 8, 2006 6:42 pm
1318
Folks, I feel I may have mislead by simply pointing out this part of Marxist theory on how slave society began. Mislead because I myself totally disagree with...
Dear Comrades, The philosophy of Hegel has originated from Plato.Plato thought that there is a unity of Mind and Nature within thought forms and he named the...
So what happens to the 'categories' in Marx? Are you suggesting they turn out to be grounded in the labour process? If they are, would they be the same...
... Sent: Tuesday, June 06, 2006 5:34 AM Subject: [hegel-marx] Marx/Hegel relation Dear Comrades, ASIM: "The philosophy of Hegel has originated from...
The claims about Marx here are nonsense. (1) "Because for Marx materialistic philosophy doesn't begin from the world of nature." An unclear statement. And...
<<<<<The philosophy of Hegel has originated from Plato>>>>>>>> I don't understand the point of your post. Are you implying that Hegel's philosophy begins...
Dear Comrade, It's very easy for you to pass judgement on my views as non-sense.I have not claimed that I am absolutely right,but what I have understood I...
Stephen: I would not call Marx's thought "dualistic" becaucse he viewed thought as the product of matter, namely the brain. Only in this sensem I think, is...
On your questions, in reverse order: (2) What is practice? It is man's interchange with nature and the management of his social organization. Where does man ...
It does seem to me that the key passage for Marx's "materialism" is what Asim has quoted, from the "Theses on Feuerbach." (reproduced below) Even if you think...
Asim: I for one do not think your views as nonsense and I think that those who do harbor an unhealthy conceit. Now to the points you raise here. I don't think...
Dear Comrades, Thanks for correcting me and opening the new aspects of debate. First of all let me share my veiws on Comrade Wylie's comments. Wylie:Now to the...
Hi Asim, As I think another post has already indicated, when Marx says - as you quoted him - "the active side was developed abstractly by idealism" Marx is ...
Pete Mason
peter.mason3@...
Jul 5, 2006 9:07 pm
1331
A few comments, interleaved below: ... I'm a little confused by this exchange. I need to re-read the relevant passages, but I surmise that 'by the active...
Cook, Daniel J. "Marx's Critique Of Philosophical Language." Philosophy and Phenomenological Research. JE 82; 42: 530-554. AB: Though Marx never systematically...
10th Anniversary of <http://marx.org/reference/archive/hegel/>Hegel-by-HyperText The 23rd October 2006 marks the 10th anniversary of the launching of ...
I noticed in my old Penguin edition (1977) of Marx Early writings Lucio Colletti writes in the Introduction that Engels "was the first to employ" the term...
... George L. Kline explains all this in "The Myth of Marx's Materialism," in Philosophical Sovietology: The Pursuit of a Science, edited by Helmut Dahn,...
Can anyone tell me I am wrong if I say that before Kojeve made a big deal about the "master-servant dialectic" in The Phenomenology, this section had been...
Andy, Well, I wouldn't say that Findlay ignored the Phenomenology as he wrote a paragraph by paragraph interpretation, however little I think it is worth, in...
That's my view of the situation exactly, Chris. Just BTW, is there anyone in a position to tell me whether Francis Fukuyama has ever read Hegel? From his...
Mr. Blunden, I have seen no evidence whatsoever of Fukayama's having read Hegel - that is, besides overt references and quotations on pages 39, 59-69, 75, 83,...
You are quite right, Roger, about all those quotes from Hegel in "End of History and the Last Man". I should apologise for forcing you to compile such a list...
And yet, despite all this reading and quoting which Roger enumerates so extensively, Fukayama can write, towards the beginning of his original essay “the end...
Mmm, I guess I opened a powder-keg here by mentioning Fukuyama. Let me say that while I share the widespread hostility to Fukuyama, I do also find that he has...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
