Dear colleagues The first meeting of the London Marx-Hegel reading group. Will take place at 6.00 pm this Wednesday, 5 October, in Room D104, 1st floor,...
Stephen, My name is Chris and you can address me as such, no need for Mr. 666, though that is quite funny. The stupid web address has more to do with the...
Thanks Stephen and Andy, My reading buddy and I went back to 207-208 yestarday and i think we made a little headway. One thing we noticed in 208 was the...
On another list (OPE-L) there was some discussion today about the English tranaslation for "darstellung" in Marx. How is "darstellung" rendered into English ...
Michael Inwood's "Hegel Dictionary" has an extensive entry on "Representation and Conception", in German more or less "vorstellung" and "Begriff". He mentions...
It is of course the richness of Hegel which makes diverse interpretations possible, a richness reflecting the complexity of subjectivity, in which the whole...
Andy wrote: That said, I would like to ask you what you and your reading ... the emergence ... their ... consciousness" ... spirit is ... relations is ... ...
... Chris: I agree: Hegel wasn't a materialist -- historical or otherwise. Of course, he had a great knowledge (at least for a philosopher) of natural/material...
Hi Chris, I went back to 207 myself. However, I got stuck on the first word "This", which put me in mind that the "unhappy consciousness" is itself a result ...
Chris, have you ever read Hegel' first draft of The Phenomenology? I am going to paste a big slab chosen at random from The SYstem of Ethical Life. Marx woulld...
Andy, I have not read his first draft. I am also entirely unprepared to have this discussion, primarily on grounds of time and knowledge of Hegel, but as much...
I really thnk that until one has grapsed that Hegel is talking about people, it's very difficult to make headway with his material. Andy ... -- Andy Blunden ...
Curious. Coming to similar conclusions regarding Lenin's revision of Marx's theory of practice as interpreted by Ilyenkov. While Marx's theory of practical...
Andy, While I am quite sure that is true and we tend to read Hegel that way, I am not sure that makes his work 'historical materialism', a term I don't even...
Sure. I presume I put "historical materialism" in inverted commas. But look, the way you were discussing "unhappy consciousness" I find difficult to relate to....
... ____________________________________________________ Do you Yahoo!? The New Yahoo! Movies: Check out the Latest Trailers, Premiere Photos and full Actor...
Dear colleagues The revised programme of the London Marx-Hegel reading group may be seen at http://www.staff.city.ac.uk/andy.denis/reading_group.htm. The next...
This is the idea: http://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/hegel/works/hi/history3.htm#036 but expressed very much in Hegelian terms, so Engels would need to...
This post is being copied from hegel-intro list, as it has been suggested that it can receive better response here. Irrelevant portions removed. ... There are...
Makc
makc@...
Dec 2, 2005 2:50 pm
1148
Makc, I don't understand this "missing paragraphs" question. What's wrong with http://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/hegel/works/sl/slquant.htm#SL99 ? And...
Hi Makc, Firstly, I am glad to hear that Paul Trejo is still on the go, I had concluded that he might have died as he disappeared from all the Hegel lists I...
... Stephen, I added paragraph numbers to the Miller translation: http://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/hegel/works/hl/hl000.htm to facilitate discussion...
To All: All right, "missing paragraphs" part is officially cancelled. In order of appearence in my e-mail, To Andy Blunden: AB> Makc, I don't understand this...
Makc
makc@...
Dec 5, 2005 7:21 am
1152
The key link between Marx's dialectic and Hegel's dialectic is Spinoza. Hegel makes the argument that Spinoza subscribed to an "Oriental conception of...
I can't answer your question, but I would like you to substantiate your assertion that Marx got his notion of dialectic from Spinoza. ... From: Gary Geiser...
Wait a minute, Ralph. I didn't mean to give the impression that Marx got his dialectic from Spinoza. He got it from Hegel, and naturally other philosophers who...
I can't make sense out of any of this. As for Spinoza's influence on Marx, I have found scanty references to Spinoza in Marx's corpus and none of them say...
For an ex-marxist, its only scant references as you say, the rest is in having read the fundamental texts and then reading Spinozas ETHICS in particular, its...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
