Bob: This is supposed to be a law of *logic*, and thus relate only to the *contents* of thought. The time-frame of mental operations should be irrelevant. ...
Arkadi, In my examination of Erdmann's opinions about Hegel's logic, I found very little worthwhile and nothing at all impressive. Learn to read Hegel...
Paul, Thanks for the "caveat". However, in this case Erdmann seems rather faithful to his source, namely Hegel: \\\\\\\\\ § 882 The other expression of the...
Dear Group, first some explications on the lists of helpful literature for reading the science of logic (i will cover your specific questions in a separate...
Hi Arkadi, ... I think this is misleading in several ways. We are here in a footnote. In it, Erdmann mentions the traditional law of identity as "A=A", which...
Kai, Thanks. I did not realize this was a translation. So, the "rule" Erdmann gives is a practical piece of advice: "do not be distracted, concentrate on what...
Kai: It seems that what you're saying is that the subtlety, and therefore the true meaning, of Hegel's thought is lost to those not adept with German. If one...
Hi Arkadi, ... No, remember that we are not in a psychological text about howto think properly, but in a text about (Hegel's) logic (it is also not a text...
Hi Ben, ... It seems that what you're saying is that the subtlety, and therefore the true meaning, of Hegel's thought is lost to those not adept with German....
Here is a worthy essay by Paul E. Trejo: http://philosophy.eserver.org/hegel-christianity.html I wish to present a partial rebuttal, while agreeing with...
... The overwhelming ... Dear Paul, A book that you might find to be not totally without merit is Hans Kung's _The Incarnation of God_ (1970, English...
As a sideways look at Hegel as Lutheran , I believe it was Pritchard who documented Hegel's lutheranism in another section,I would introduce my views on this...
Bob, Hegel was a Lutheran, but a very marginal one. I've spoken with some Lutheran ministers about Hegel, and they only smile. Hegel was more influenced by...
Paul-Thanks for your reply.You and others on this list may be interested in this essay"Hegel,Lutheranism and Contemporary Theology by Gary D Badcock the url...
what's the best intro on Hegel idea of History? ...something accessable to lay man please...anyidea? :)...
S M
smohamadi74@...
May 28, 2009 9:16 pm
2260
Bob, It's a mildly interesting essay that misses much of the essence of Hegel's theology. The learned writer was more careful to communicate with his own...
I'm attending college at night and was give an article to read in my Political Science class discussing Hegel called Hegel: Civil Society and the State. I have...
Stephen, Yes, it's amusing that Mary Baker Edddy, founder of "Christian Science" Church, quoted material from the Hegelian, Francis Lieber, without giving ...
 Stephen,  I believe that Hegel's LECTURES ON THE PHILOSOPHY OF RELIGION (1818-1831) are among the most important documents we possess in the study of...
In fact, the Hegelian doctrine of miracles is that they never happened.? Hase gave his own opinion, and Lieber published Hase's opinion, but simply because...
Does H. anywhere explicitly define the meaning of this term in its (onto-)logical/dialectical application (as, e.g., in _Science of Logic_, section 150)? I am...
Dear Arkadi, To be very brief and terse, my take on Hegel's 'Bewegung' is that he refers strictly to dialectical movement, which is self-referent because it...
Hi Paul, Yes, this helps for a starter. Did I get you right that it is, say, the fact that a Totality is *both* a single Number *and* a multiple Quantity, that...
Let me draw your attention to the following: <http://www.amazon.com/Absolute-Boot-Journeyman-Cobbler-Philosophy/dp/1933237139/> Cheers! Eric Eric v.d. Luft,...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
