As part of a class I'm taking, we were given a reading assignment from The Phenomenology which dealt with the Lord-Bondsman parable. In the very first sentence...
Self-consciousness can exist only by being its own object. But to be an object is to be for another. So, Hegel's seems to be saying that consciousness can...
Hi, Hegel often begins with a succinct statement at the start of a chapter and only develops the argument logically later. This is obviously a different mode...
Thanks to all for taking the time to reply. I've sent the followoing response to the list a few days ago but it has yet to appear. My apologies if this...
Self-consciousness can exist only by being its own object. But to be an object is to be for another. So, Hegel's seems to be saying that consciousness can...
I'm just starting to study Hegel, so I am just feeling my way along too. What I've gotten from Harris (Hegel's Ladder) and the J. Bernstein lectures is that...
My understanding is that the possibilities (1) and (2) on your list are done away with in the section on "Consciousness" as presupposing some "powers" ...
Hi Arkadi: Are you suggesting that the proper interpretation is to consider self- consciousness as an act occurring in the present? If that's so, it would...
... consciousness as an act occurring in the present? ... Yes, I do. And, frankly, to me this meaning appears as quite straightforward. Consciousness is a...
... self- ... Thanks for confirming what, for me, was the crux of the issue. ... I know what you mean. Quite often the answers to questions from beginners...
Sorry, I did not mean it to be condescending. I am a beginner myself. I just shared my perception. Arkadi ... From: amanetti2000 <amanetti2000@...> Date:...
Professor Bernstein in his lecture (http://www.bernsteintapes.com/lectures/Hegel/31ObservingReasonA.mp3) states tha for reason (as a form of consciousness)...
... (http://www.bernsteintapes.com/lectures/Hegel/31ObservingReasonA.mp3) states tha for reason (as a form of consciousness) "faith in God is a logical...
OK -- thanks. I know these issues can seem like tedious minutia, but to me they're foundational. Overall, the responses have helped me resolve my initial ...
... Bernstein is not just referring to this fact, but attempts to explaing it. It is this explanation of his that I am trying to decipher. ... In the form of...
... Well, amanetti2000, by my reading, the fight-to-the-death scenario of Hegel's narrative on Self-consciousness is the key to the narrative. Recognition is...
... (http://www.bernsteintapes.com/lectures/Hegel/31ObservingReasonA.mp3) ... Despite his brilliance, Sartre was handicapped by his atheism, in my (Hegelian)...
... I expressed myself poorly. I didn't doubt it (after all, this is Hegel). I just couldn't make sense of it. I think I'm on firmer ground now. ... Yes -- I...
Hi, Paul: It's a pity you could not Bernstein's lecture; I would be very interested to learn what you think of his argument. Perhaps you can access it through...
... While that is true, Amanetti, Hegel won't allow us to make a one-sided dictum out of it. It is *equally* true that we are Individuals, capable of Free...
Are you suggesting that the proper interpretation is to consider self- consciousness as an act occurring in the present? ... Yes, I do. And, frankly, to me...
Paul and others, I thought that this Professor Bernstein was an engaging talker and I listened to two of the lectures. Even the mannerisms and en passants are...
Paul, Welcome back to the group. We missed you. You said, "Despite his brilliance, Sartre was handicapped by his atheism, in my (Hegelian) view. Sartre merely...
I had a recent discussion with friend (who is sympathetic toward Marx) and she claimed that Hegel was really an individualist. Initially that struck me as...
jacostopoulo@...
May 5, 2008 5:13 pm
2187
I had a recent discussion with friend (who is sympathetic toward Marx) and she claimed that Hegel was really an individualist. Initially that struck me as...
jacostopoulo@...
May 5, 2008 5:13 pm
2188
Hegel as an individualist? In response to the Tue29Apr08 post by Jim C: Well, Jim, by my reading, the question of Hegel and individualism cannot be answered...
Dear All I conducted an Interview with Professor Domenico Losurdo (President of International Society Hegel-Marx for Dialectical Thought) and Professor Andreas...
I've got a question: In the introduction to the "Encyclopedia" §7 Hegel very clearly distinguishes between philosophy and empirical science. Does anyone know...
Hello, everybody in the list. I'm Lucas, I'm twenty years old and I'm on the third year of philosophy college. I just joined this list, and, as my first post,...
Philosophy, for Kant, is knowledge entirely derived from concepts, and hence can speak to the apriori, or necessary and universal level of discourse...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
