Dear Hegel List, After reading more of the interesting history by the former member of the original Hegel School, namely, Johann Erdmann (ca. 1870) I decided...
Greetings Paul, and thanks for your review/critique of Erdmann's appendix to his two volume history of philosophy. Judging from your demands in your critique,...
... Well, Kai, much depends upon who wrote that blurb. As with all commentaries on Hegel, I prefer to draw my own estimations of the value of any given...
Dear Paul, 1. please take any discussion of the appendix to Erdman's philosophy of history, concerning the "dissolution of the Hegel School" after Hegel's ...
... Well, Kai, until I'm convinced of Erdmann's credentials according to my own sense of reason, I won't pursue a group reading of Erdmann's OUTLINES OF LOGIC...
I am responding here as a reply to Paul's request to read Hegel directly.This brings up a problem about translation-for example one must,if one doesnt read...
There is an earlier US translation of the Science of Logic. trans. Johnston & Struthers. (London: Allen/Muirhead Library of Philosophy, 1929, 2nd impression...
Hi, Can I just comment that I hope you do continue to share your thoughts with us Paul, as this has been a most stimulating thread so far. I would be...
Those of you that have not read John Watson's "Schelling's Transcendental Idealism" might be interested in the following book review, posted on Amazon. ...
Stephen, Thank for your text. I thinking in it. Is very interesting.In the Wastebook´s (my traslation in Spanish), the Jena´s Hegels is full insigth about...
The New SPACE (The New School for Pluralistic Anti-Capitalist Education) Presents Reading Hegel's Preface to the _Phenomenology of Spirit_ Alex Steinberg ...
That's interesting. I believe Watson was a Canadian philosopher of the generation after E Caird (who wrote on Kant from a Hegelian standpoint). He also wrote...
Two new versions of the common misconception of Hegel and the Dialectic as "Thesis-Antithesis-Synthesis" that are becoming more and more popular. I don't see...
Hi, I'm new to this list - and to the study of Hegel. My introduction to Hegelian thought has been through Marx and various 'Hegelian Marxists' (Korsch,...
Hi Don Why not start a study group with Hegel's Preface to the Phenomenology? Jesse From: "dantenen" <dantenen@...> Reply-To: hegel-intro@yahoogroups.com...
Jesse Schwartz
jesse@...
Sep 11, 2007 12:04 pm
2128
For those of you who are interested, the next posts will contain some text from sources about the all-to-common mistake describing the Hegelian Dialectic as...
The Hegel Legend of "Thesis-Antithesis-Synthesis" Gustav E. Mueller Journal of the History of Ideas, Vol. 19, No. 3. (Jun., 1958), pp. 411-414. More from: ...
In a message dated 9/11/07 3:03:08 PM Pacific Daylight Time, ymno@... ... Hello, I would point out that the negation of the negation implies a unity in ...
The article you posted is a personal attack on Marx ("The few passages in Marx' writings that resemble philosophy are not his own"???). not a well-reasoned...
A friend's response to this general debate: "This is pretty well known, especially among the more Hegelian Marxists, but I've never seen its importance. The...
Dear people, Is there anyone out there who would like to study with me, Hegel's Preface to the Phenomenology using Yirmiyahu's Yovel's excellent translation...
Jesse Schwartz
jesse@...
Oct 29, 2007 9:03 am
2135
Jesse, I only have the Miller translation, but would be willing to discuss any aspects of the Preface with you, being a relatively amateur Hegelian myself. Of...
I would very much like to study the preface the the Phenomenology, however I have the Miller Translation, published by oxford. ... [Non-text portions of this...
I'm all for it too, particularly as it's a short text. (I tried the same thing myself years ago on the now defunct hegel-dialognet, with mixed results.)...
Hi, Yes - same here. I'd like to study the Preface but again only have the Miller. All the best, Julian ... however I ... Hegel's Preface ... translation and...
Dear people A few days ago I annnounced the formation of a group to study the Preface to the Phenomenology. Have gotten a pretty good response,four people have...
Jesse Schwartz
jesse@...
Oct 31, 2007 6:52 am
2140
I'm interested as well (was already reading it!), and I am reading this translation: http://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/hegel/works/ph/phprefac.htm I...
Dear People Thank you for a fine response to my suggestion to form a study group.I suggest that we begin with the first six numbered sections in Miller's ...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
