Dear Hegel-Intro, . The man who became Pope Benedict XVI was once known as Bishop Joseph C. Ratzinger. Since he was a German scholar, we shouldn't be...
... Well, Anthony, it certainly seems so at this point. Popper tried to accuse Hegel of historicism, presuming that Marx's economic determinism was somehow a...
... Hello Paul. It's good to see you're back from vacation--or wherever the hell it is you've been. Over at the main Hegel list today I submited the following...
... I was in the process of moving from Northern California to Southern California and getting settled. Whew! ... Yes, John, I'm aware of this excellent and...
... Well, Anthony, I disagree. Hegel's notion of freedom is a bit different than the ordinary notion of *arbitrary* freedom. For Hegel, freedom exists within...
Dear Hegel-Intro, I'll continue to review the 1968 writings of Bishop Joseph Ratzinger on the philosophy of GWF Hegel. It may be of interest to some because...
Hi all, I've noticed that people no longer discuss on this Hegel group lately. Paul, do you think that it matters what bishop Ratzinger wrote in discussing...
... Hi Vant. Yes, I think it matters that the Pope of Rome discussed Hegel in his early days, and that he misunderstood key points. It's interesting because...
I think Paul's comments about Ratzinger have to do directly with Hegel. The specific objections that Paul is raising against Ratzinger's critique of Hegel, I...
... Welcome Bob. In case oyu want an introduction to Hegel's philosophy, you may be interested in the http://groups.yahoo.com/group/hegel-intro/ list which is...
Kai, when you wrote <reading the Lectures on the Philosophy of History is the perfect ... Did you mean to write the Lectures on the History of Philosophy? ...
Dear Hegel-Intro, I'll continue to review the 1968 remarks about Hegel by Bishop Joseph Ratzinger since he was named Pope Benedict XVI this year. Bishop...
Question: what ***YOU THINK*** is Hegel's "mediation"? Now that I have raised it in my last message to alt.philosophy, I thought it would be good idea to bring...
Makc
makc@...
Oct 24, 2005 9:53 am
1792
PT> Bishop believes that since scholarly secondary literature about most PT> philosophers is very reliable, secondary literature about Hegel must PT> also be...
Makc
makc@...
Oct 24, 2005 9:53 am
1793
okay, folks, this is part 2. http://www-rohan.sdsu.edu/dept/phil/hegelgls.htm sais: "13) mediation A connecting link, or relationship between two things. ...
Makc
makc@...
Oct 24, 2005 12:55 pm
1794
Makc wrote: akc ... Well, Makc, if you would proceed a bit slower you might recognize that this thread on Bishop Ratzinger's dispute over Hegel and Historicism...
PT> It is important PT> to read Hegel's primary texts, and not just secondary literature. PT> That's a key point. While I din't said it is not, and in fact, by...
Makc
makc@...
Oct 24, 2005 2:50 pm
1796
... Well -- insofar as you're seeking Hegel's idea of mediation, Makc, these definitions don't even scratch the surface. All they show so far is that...
Thanks a lot! Thant´s an interesting discussion! May i ask if it´s possible to receive mails in luismariaba@...? There i have more virtual "place". ...
Luis María Baliña
luismaba@...
Oct 24, 2005 11:45 pm
1798
Thanx, Paul. ... But if relation is not transitive, there is no relation between A and C, neither immediate, nor "mediated". Right? So, it's either "mediation"...
Makc
lucky_try@...
Oct 25, 2005 8:58 pm
1799
Having left with no other choise but to handle Hegel's original texts myself, I am now up to examine what does Hegel say about mediation in his "Encyclopaedia...
Makc
lucky_try@...
Oct 26, 2005 4:52 am
1800
perhaps, the key thing to understand this wordplay is to define how "middle term" is used. no matter how "general" this concept ("mediation") is, I don't buy...
Makc
makc@...
Oct 26, 2005 8:28 am
1801
... You're right, Makc, to hold out for an easier explanation. It can be done. ... All right, Makc, I'll try again. First, however, I'm glad that I showed you...
Thanx, Paul, for your atempt. You said, PT> (4) To say this in another way -- PURE BEING refers only to PT> the Present Moment, which is to say, the IMMEDIATE...
Makc
makc@...
Oct 27, 2005 6:28 am
1803
... Because, Makc, Present-time is the realm of Sense Certainty. Our five senses are HERE and NOW. We SEE in Present. We HEAR in the Present. We TASTE and...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
