This is how the Phenomenology of Spirit's chapter 3 starts: Para. 132: "Consciousness has found "seeing" and "hearing", etc., pass away in the dialectic...
... Right, Vant, insofar as Hegel has begun with the crudest form of Consciousness, namely, Sense-certainty, which is the pointing stage (or perhaps more...
Thanks Paul, that answers my query. I could never have come close to the understanding you have given and the difference between Kant and Hegel. ... also have...
... In that case, Carol, I'm glad I could guide you in this direction. Hegel can be understood best as one who answers Kant because that is what Hegel himself...
Dear Paul Trejo, I am just reading Danile Berthold-Bond's "Hegel's Grand Synthesis: A Study of Being, Thought and History." What is your evaluation of this...
Ian Kluge
iankluge@...
Dec 8, 2004 6:12 pm
1583
I'm trying to get a grip on a world spirit using Hegel's concept of spirit. I have begun by looking at Observing Reason in THE PHENOMENOLOGY. Looking at what...
... Well, Ian, I'll be brief for now. It's a *great* book. Professor Berthold-Bond is a long-time member of the HSA, and a member of the first Hegel Lists at...
... This is gross propaganda (and dare I say, sappy). What exactly is the argument of the book? Unfortunately, (and I speak for myself here)I immediately...
Carole, As per usual with Paul on Marx, he has some partial truths which he uses to sloppily lump together an extremely wide-range of disparate ideas, whose...
Well said. 'I perceive you as fortunate, Ian' is just patronizing. Why is Ian 'fortunate'? Because he has chanced upon what Trejo calls a great Hegel book?...
... i never saw paul trejo saying this, and i've read him all year long. ... not only is that an incomplete sentence, but paul trejo never said that either....
... nobody can prove anything to a prejudiced mind. ... wrong. people from all over the world ask paul trejo about hegel because they can't find this stuff in...
The problem is that Trejo is a charlatan who thinks he has everyone fooled. Ever notice how "Fred" comes on the scene just when Paul leaves, and vice versa?...
... Well, Will, you have already disturbed my vacation with your personal attacks. You should be talking about Hegel here, and not about me. I am no...
... I'd like to introduce myself to the Hegel-Intro list. My name is Jed and I am pursuing graduate studies in philosophy (unfortunately, I am currently an ...
... i'm not paul trejo, jed. will's got some bug up his ass. lots of us have benefitted from paul's help with hegel since early 2002 when this list was...
... Dear list, Just for fun let's look at "the Pomo kid"'s first post on the Hegel list. Notice below that "=Fred" is writing from Paul's email account....
... jeezuz, jackwak, are you trying to beat a confession out of somebody? it's none of your business but paul and I do know each other. we've worked together...
You're a classy guy Paul, and honest. I guess that's why so many of the long term Hegel-List contributers respect you so much. All the best, Randall...
Paul, I feel quite embarassed about your charade. If anyone is in doubt about it, consider that the answers given here to my points are written in exactly the...
roger, you don't know what you're talking about with regard to me or to paul. get over it. why don't you just talk about hegel here? that's the purpose of...
Dear members, ... isn't there a supervisor present who ought to ban such spleen from the page? Aren't the rules that we should respect each other and Hegel? ...
-x-snip----- Moderator's (Kai) up front note: Well folks, I just mentioned that we need to close this debatte in order to come back to Hegel. But I thought...
Back to Hegel. Perhaps we can resume from a basic question, and build our way back up to the level we were on before. So, off the top of my head: Hegel's...
... back up to ... of the ... we look ... movements ... another stage, ... should ... would ... say, ethnic ... been ... say? ... present his ... element in ...
My German isn't very good. Can someone tell me what "sie" is in the final clause of this sentence from Das Absolute Wissen (Absolute Knowing) in THE...
Thanks John But I wanted to get the Hegel discussion going again - what bearing does this have on Hegel's view of history? It's all very well conjuring that ...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
