In response to the Thu31Jan08 post by debabrata banejee: I appreciate your comment that secret schools that suddenly spring up and claim great authority are to...
Dear Debabrata Banerjee, thank you for your input. I apreciate your interest in Erdman (and obviously in Michelet and may be Rosenkranz as well) and your long...
Hi Paul, ... I agree with this statement in general, but insofar it concenrs my original mail, it is based on a misunderstanding, as I do not mention a "secret...
... I think this is one of the problem of Erdmann's Logic. 'Mode' or 'modality' belongs on the one side to Spinoza's philosophy of the substance in which it is...
Hi all I have an elementary knowledge of Hegel. I would like to read some books and articles which give me a good overview of the overall scope, method and...
... (I'm not sure what you mean by the last part of that sentence, "where the use...", btw, so I leave it out for this mail) Michelet keeps the name measure,...
In response to bid_d: Presuming English is your language of choice, I'd recommend to you the well-known book, GWF HEGEL: THE SYSTEM, by Howard Kainz (1996)....
Kai In his Heidelberger Encyclopaedia Hegel explicitly exclude 'mode' as the third after quality and quantity. Kant does not know this third ('measure') and...
thank you very much for the suggestion - i am looking forward to reading kainz's book. ... Sent from Yahoo! - a smarter inbox. [Non-text portions of this...
Greetings Beat, thanks for taking the time to answer me. ... The Heidelberger Encyclopedia is available online at http://hegel.net/hegelwerke Its first...
Hi and welcome to our list! (a) Probably most important: this list is dedicated to the discussion of Hegelians after Hegel's death, including people only...
hello to all greetings let me begin with a commonplace in hypotheticals : Suppose i get a telephonic call from a close friend of mine who stays in Shanghi that...
Dear Paul Trejo, Nice to hear that Eardman did not know very well Hegel but a paradox emerges whan you refer to two German Hegelians - yes, i have read some of...
Dear list, I recieved today a mail from debabrata banerjee ("heraclitusmisanthrope"), which I think was meant to go to the public list, as it is an answer to...
Greetings, debabrata banerjee, ... spelled the surname Erdman too. I do not check the monitor in some cases to verify how I have written due to a certain eye...
... Well, Debabrata, with due respect to your wide reading, I cannot agree that "Erdmann's Hegel...was alive then." The date of Erdmann's book, OUTLINES OF...
Dear Kai and Hegel scholars, First, thanx for posting all the messages, though one among them had not been decided whether to post or not. Probably an...
Hi Paul ... Well, first of all, you neglect that you are talking of teh date of teh *translation* of the *4th edition* of Erdmann's Logic. The first 3 editions...
Dear list, as some paricipants have left this list the last days (while noone has left the months before) and OTOH (on the other hand) we had some rather very...
Dear Debabrata Banerjee, in order to keep focus, I'd like mainly concentrate on the Erdmann and Michelet questions (however, below you promis to mainly discuss...
How do you moderate a list that has been inactive for months, even years, at a time? What is the point? ... [Non-text portions of this message have been...
Greetings, Ralph, ... basicaly, one can moderate a list (a) by supressing mails which are off topic and one can moderate (b) by taking care of the list with...
hi. Please correct me in my intuition regarding your `elementary knowledge of Hegel'. Thee are nice, aesthetically designed and formatted books, not exactly...
I do not see reason enough for Walter Jäschke to use Erdman's interpretation of Hegel's SL. However, since you have mentioned the term "phenomena" I would...
marko ivakovic
markoi@...
Feb 16, 2008 8:50 pm
707
To that end, I found that the 2006 book "The Opening of Hegel's Logic" by Stephen Houlgate was excellent and very helpful to a beginner in ways that other...
Hello, Kai Froeb has raised a basic question and an enigma about the categories and structure of Being, making it more philosophical by bringing German terms...
Dear list, I just saw that yahoogroups, which host our mailing list/discussion group has classified 5 mails of the last days as "spam" (unfortunately, they...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
