Skip to search.
harrypotterforseekers · Harry Potter for Seekers

Group Information

  • Members: 160
  • Category: Adults
  • Founded: Aug 3, 2004
  • Language: English
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Hear how Yahoo! Groups has changed the lives of others. Take me there.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
Chapter 21 discussion introduction   Message List  
Reply Message #2422 of 4317 |
Hello everyone,

Here is the introduction for chapter 21. Have fun discussing.

Introduction to chapter 21

Chapter summary
Harry talks with Ron and Hermione about apparition, the mystery of
how to get Slughorn's memory and Lavender's affections for Ron.
During the discussion Harry finds a new curse in his potions
textbook. This curse is called Sectumsempra, labeled "For Enemies",
and wishes to test it. Also apparition practices in Hogsmeade and
the following tests are announced.

Kreacher and Dobby show up to report on Malfoy's doings, including
those regarding Malfoy's regular use of the Room of Requirement. The
elves state that a "variety of students" have been keeping watch for
Draco while he is in the room. Harry determines that these students
are none other than Crabbe and Goyle, their appearance transformed
by Polyjuice Potion stolen from Slughorn. They could have been
dropping the scales and toad-spawn when someone passes to tell Draco
not to come out. Harry decides to spend some time trying to get into
the Room of Requirement.

The next morning in the Daily Prophet there is news that Mundungus
Fletcher has been arrested and sent to Azkaban, someone called
Octavius Pepper has vanished and a nine-year arrested for trying to
kill his grandparents, they think he was under the Imperius Curse.
And Hermione thinks Harry should focus on getting Slughorn's memory
instead of trying to figure out how to follow Draco into the Room of
Requirement. Harry tries to enter the Room of Requirement and fails
every time.

In Potions Snape explains the difference between ghost and Inferi,
Seamus asks about Mundungus pretending to be an Inferius when
caught. Snape calls Mundungus a smelly sneak-thief and picks on
Harry again.

After Potions Ron and Harry have to flee from Lavender and enter a
bathroom where they meet Moaning Myrtle. Myrtle reveals she's been
talking with a boy who has been crying a lot.
The next weekend Ron and Hermione go to practice apparition in
Hogsmeade and Harry tries to get in the Room of Requirement again.
By the way, Slughorn seems to be doing his best to avoid Harry all
the time. Harry fails again and Harry runs into a disheveled Tonks
looking for Dumbledore. Back with Hermione and Ron he wonders if she
loved Sirius.

The extra apparition training in Hogsmeade did well for Ron and he
finally is improving.

Questions to start discussion
- Why wouldn't the Room of Requirement open up for Harry? My
impression is he really needed to know what Malfoy was doing.
- Ron disagrees with Snape on the best way to tackle a
Patronus. Is there another way except the Patronus and what form
could that countermeasure take?
- It is official in this chapter that what House Elves do is
apparition. They are able to this in Hogwarts with its wards. Can
this be interpreted as an implication of how powerful House Elf
magic is?
- There doesn't seem to be happening very much in this
chapter. What is the point of it?






Wed Dec 13, 2006 11:05 am

pinkfoxranger
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Message #2422 of 4317 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

Hello everyone, Here is the introduction for chapter 21. Have fun discussing. Introduction to chapter 21 Chapter summary Harry talks with Ron and Hermione...
Eva
pinkfoxranger Offline Send Email
Dec 13, 2006
12:08 pm

... Jayne: Hi Eva. I just wanted to acknowledge your introduction and to thank you. I've been a little preoccupied with the question "Is Harry Potter Evil?";...
Jayne
naniejay Offline Send Email
Dec 15, 2006
5:27 am

... Orna: Thanks Eva for your summary and your questions. It made me think that something about apparating seems to be around the point. Here are my thoughts...
ornadv Offline Send Email Dec 18, 2006
8:50 pm

... The whole issue of apparition not working in Hogwarts, and Hogwarts magical protection in general, is fairly inconsistent. Consider: 1. House elves can...
harrypottertorah
harrypottert... Offline Send Email
Dec 19, 2006
12:07 pm

... Hogwarts ... Fire ... Orna: I'll try the "more complicated" route: It seems that apparition is the most advanced way of moving – or getting from one...
ornadv Offline Send Email Dec 20, 2006
10:41 am

... Hi Seekers, and especially you, Orna. I think you are on something important; the wizards didn't enslave the elves because they were weak, but because they...
iris_ft Offline Send Email Dec 20, 2006
8:01 pm

Chris: Hello, all. This is quite a long post, and includes some background reading, so I suggest you get yourself a nice cup of tea and find a comfy chair :- )...
Christina Nihill
christinanihill Offline Send Email
Dec 21, 2006
8:51 am

... wrote: Why wouldn't the Room of Requirement open up for Harry? My impression is he really needed to know what Malfoy was doing. Jayne: I think that the...
Jayne
naniejay Offline Send Email
Dec 19, 2006
1:44 pm

Jayne: I think that the Room of Requirement only opens up if you need to access the room, and not just because you want to access it. Valerie: I don't think...
Valerie Yeary
vyeary Offline Send Email
Dec 19, 2006
3:41 pm

... access the room, and not just because you want to access it. Valerie: I don't think it's that complicated. How does the room assess want vs. need? Did...
Jayne
naniejay Offline Send Email
Dec 19, 2006
8:19 pm

... impression is ... Yes, I think Hermoine says something of the sort to Harry when he's fuming about not being able to find the room. She points out that ...
Alice
loptwyn Offline Send Email
Dec 19, 2006
3:49 pm

... It wouldn't open up until Harry neede to hide something. That was the thought necessary to get to the junkyard section of the RoR. ... Why do I get the...
Deborah
weaslediva Offline Send Email
Dec 29, 2006
11:44 pm

Eva, I don¡¦t think we¡¦ve ¡¥spoken¡¦ before, so ¡§Hello¡¨ and thank you for your chapter summary. ... Leah: Orna, Christina and Jayne have all...
littleleahstill Offline Send Email Jan 7, 2007
11:58 pm
Advanced

Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines NEW - Help