Judy, that sounds about right to me. I personally would not agree with Tom's assessment that "Today the consensus is that the Pastorals are likely Pauline."...
Hi Rick, You're far more charitable than I would have been with Tom's absurd advice. To repeat it here (leaving out the severely inapt hammer simile): "My...
Tom says: to: Judy Raymond Brown would not be my choice of an unbiased survey taker. However, more importent is the various scholars basis for their view. tom...
Mark says: Judy, that sounds about right to me. I personally would not agree with Tom's assessment that "Today the consensus is that the Pastorals are likely...
John Moon raises several questions relating to what is meant by authenticity, and by what we mean when we ask whether X wrote T. I'll take a crack at answering...
Mike wrote: “I've just perused the NIV Study Bible, and zowie, is their take different! Though acknowledging authorship questions, in each and every case...
Mark's blog posting today contains videos of his recent appearance on the CBN (Christian Broadcasting Network) programme* "The 700 Club", in a segment...
Last Thursday, Chris posted on John Meier's recent work on Thomas: http://pejeiesous.com/2013/01/24/john-meier-on-thomas-and-the-synoptics/ A couple weeks...
With its 35 postings, January was a bit sub-par for the month ("par" being about 46, January being the highest-volume month on average), though still...
Forum members, Based on what I was taught from Prof. Walter Russell the first step in determining authorship/dating is to use an author-centric, top-down...
To: GThos Cc: GPG In Response To: Tom Reynolds On: Text Study From: Bruce Tom's report of a method of text study is interesting. The mere idea that there ARE...
From: E Bruce Brooks Sent: Tuesday, February 05, 2013 1:27 AM To: gthomas@yahoogroups.com Cc: GPG Subject: RE: [GTh] Authorship and Dating GTh To: GThos In...
To: GThos In Response To: Jack Kilmon On: Jesus Sayings in Thomas From: Bruce Jack: Yes, a number of the genuine Jesus sayings in Thomas (about half the logia)...
I am resisting the temptation to simply dismiss Mr. Reynolds’s proposed "textual mapping" strategy out of hand because Russell's strategy assumes (a) that...
... Now Jack, you know better. Steve Davies proposed that in a paper, true, but it's had about as much acceptance as your own opinion that Mark wrote Thomas. ...
From: Mike Grondin Sent: Tuesday, February 05, 2013 3:00 PM To: gthomas@yahoogroups.com Subject: Re: [GTh] Authorship and Dating GTh ... MIKE] Now Jack,...
Response to: Rick Hubbard Professor Russell's approach assumes that the author had a point which may not be true with GTh. In addition, it may take some...
Tom Wrote: "Professor Russell's approach assumes that the author had a point which may not be true with GTh. In addition, it may take some considerable [sic]...
Reply To: Rick Hubbard If you are of the opinion that my approach presented is ill advised or will likely be unfruitful, I can certainly understand your...
Tom- It looks like you found a spell checker. Many thanks. Tom Writes: If you are of the opinion that my approach presented is ill advised or will likely be...
To: GThos In Comment on: a remark of Rick Hubbard From: Bruce I recently posted a comment on methodology with texts, not much at variance with much of what...
Hi Jack - Even the first item in your long list of Mark-Thomas parallels indicates what's wrong with the list, namely that it doesn't show what you think it...
Ran across the following the other night in a mystery novel (Lawrence Sanders, McNally's Secret, the thoughts being attributed to the main ... Perhaps overly...
Hi Mike; Yep, lots of wisdom in what "Archy" says. Nothing beats the old "let's see what happens if we do this" strategy. While 999 times out of 1,000 not much...
From: Rick Hubbard Sent: Thursday, February 14, 2013 4:14 AM To: gthomas@yahoogroups.com Subject: RE: [GTh] Detective Work & The Scientific Method Hi Mike; ...
Rick - While there may be some commonalities between the processes of invention and investigation, it's probably more confusing than anything else to mention...
Hi Rick Thanks for clarifying your remarks. A couple of follow-up comments on modern-day numbering relative to GThomas: 1. Numbering of Nag Hammadi codices:...
Just as a follow-up on Mikes observations about "numbering", the history of GTh's segregation into saying and sub-sayings is somewhat interesting (to me at...
