>P:...that by meditating one can sit and see desires come and go,
>===============
I'd like to rephrase that as "by observing present moment one can see dhammas
and their nature thus developing more and more understanding that will
eventually uproot the defilements"
>P: but my point is that one fails to see just how deep and pervasive >lobha
is....
>======================================================
Only by deeper and deeper observation and reflection can this be seen. Of course
if someone settles only on the surface level than it is fault of that person
rather than meditation itself.
It is not fault of the tool that someone misused it.
As if in daily life neyya can go deep enough for such kind of insight.
Hi Alex (kind of a p.s to Sarah later.) ... Of course not! Lobha galore for all of us in the realms of sense door experience. ... Well, you know, I can...
Hello Phil, all, ... I'd like to rephrase that as "by observing present moment one can see dhammas and their nature thus developing more and more understanding...
Alex, Phil, (Rob E.), A: "Apparently even when one is restless one is still one-pointed on one object..." Me: "What motivates someone to keep posting for years...
Hi Scott and all ... Since I have popped by and am distracting myself from the translation project I am supposed to be working on, I will carry on for another...
Hi Scott and all ... Yes, "for me", as Lukas noted... But I saw my dog get hit right in front of me, and ran down to the house to find him already there, lying...
Phil, Ph: "...I bet if people didn't know your wife died they will see you in a more sympathetic light. It's kind of ridiculous how that works, but it does. Or...
Hi Scott. ... It is personal, none the less. ... I think the answer is obvious - the person who keeps bringing them up disagrees with the predominant view and...
Hi Phil & all, ... ... S: I gave the quote from the commentary to the Abhidhammattha Sangaha before. Here's a summary as given in the Guide to CMA, Ch V,...
Hi Alex. ... This particular point surprised me and does seem confusing. I am waiting to hear about how right concentration is to be developed but is already...
Hello RobertE, all, ... I wonder about that as well. Apparently with every wholesome state there is already "right concentration". It is said in Dhs (PTS 9). ...
Hi Alex. ... I often agree with you on these issues, but on this one I think we should distinguish between the accumulation of kusala, and the way in which...
Hi Alex. ... How do you deal with the objection that the intention to purposefully cultivate kusala is an act of self-view, thinking that you can control the...
Hello RobertE, ... In that case, *any* action would be developing Self view and thus there would be no way out short of dropping motionless and thoughtless...
Hi Alex. ... I think the idea is not that we should drop all intentional action - it is specifically wrong view to think that intentional actions can lead to...
Hello RobertE, ... Of course intention can be kusala or akusala. It is not fault of meditation if a person misuses it, just like it is not fault of the tool if...
Hi Alex. ... I agree. But there is some caution about whether there is akusala cetana behind the desire to develop the path. That doesn't just apply to...
Hi RobertE, all, ... There can be less-than-ideal aspiration such as to practice Dhamma to be reborn in heaven. But even this is not akusala. It is just not...
Hello RobertE, A good quote: "The other extreme is when other people encourage you to give up exerting any control over anything at all. They tell you to try...
Hi Alex. ... What kind of control do you think can be exerted, and how does such exertion take place? Buddha did clearly state that the khandas were not-self...
Hi Alex. ... I tend to agree with this, but I understand the opposing view as well. I do agree that Buddha taught how to use meditation and other life...
Hello RobertE, all, Here is another thing: The Buddha has never said that "there is no self". In SN44.10 The Buddha refused to claim that "self doesn't exist" ...
Alex, A: "... In MN#2 the speculations about Self/No-Self are said to be inappropriate reflections and that one should contemplate 4NT instead..." Scott: Cool....
Scott, ... Is MN#2 obsolete or wrong? "18. "That person considers improperly thus: 'Did I exist in the past? Did I not exist in the past? Who was I in the...
Dear Alex, ... N: What we read here are examples of doubt about realities. Your discussion was about the non-self. There are many texts about personality...