Ben, I don't have a critical edition of Contra Celsum here. The sentence you quote is included without any note about textual problems in Chadwick's CUP ...
I hope this little intrusion into the quietude and solitude of your holiday week won't come as too troublesome. But, in about a month the Catholic Biblical...
http://www.uccf.org.uk/download/Reasonable-Faith---DVD-Order-form It's only available in the UK- in some sort of cruel and inhuman transgression against those...
... And even if your order it from the UK, it might not be playable on your DVD player. UK DVDs have a "region" play code that is incompatible with many/most...
That's the worst part. My luck if I went ahead and tried to order it (so as not to have to wait for however long its going to take them to do a North American...
With apologies for multi-posting: List folk who have decided to attend the CBA in San Jose August 4-7 are invited to join the "listers meeting"- an informal...
My humble apologies! That's HUGH Page... Not what I wrote..... thanks to James Spinti for pointing it out. (I have to go mow the lawn now to purge the bad...
Hi everyone, I am interested to learn from anyone on this list who has read Clayton Croy's book, The Mutilation of Mark's Gospel. Do you find this book's...
I've shared a review I wrote of Croy's book on my blog at http://exploringourmatrix.blogspot.com/2007/07/mutilation-of-marks-gospe l.html If I recall...
It has been some time since I looked at it, and I will have to review the book, but I was not that impressed. It was also discussed at the SBL this last fall,...
Mark wrote: I found the argument that Mt. and Luke vary from Mark the most precisely after 16:8. Yes! To me this is a strong argument for the shorter...
For me, one of Croy's strongest arguments that Mark originally continued further is a comparison with Moby Dick. Apparently, a first printing omitted the final...
... is ... wrote ... it ... Kurt: I suppose one might allow that Matthew and Luke could have used a mutilated text. But for me, how likely is that? We know...
... continued ... one ... how ... James: I actually don't find that terribly convincing. Mark's story leaves enough pointers in the story forward to a...
... But isn't it also possible that the shortened version was copied because *no complete version was available*? ... No, it need only to have happened to the...
... I actually like the 'mutilated Mark' hypothesis. It comports well with what we know about other ancient codexes, and with physical realities. BTW, did any...
I haven't yet been able to read Croy's book, but this conversation has sparked my curiosity. It seems to me from what I'm overhearing he must be arguing that...
Chris McKinney wrote ... I'm away from my copy of the book at the moment, but, if I recall correctly, Croy suggests that Mark's autograph was actually written...
Chris McKinney wrote ... Steven and Chris: This would make quite a bit of sense, and is one reason I don't have problems with this part of Croy's thesis. If I...
I appreciate this very interesting discussion. Several of you have asked after Croy's details about the mechanical aspect of his thesis. He argues on pages...
Thanks Stephen, Mark, and Kurt for enlightening me! Although I knew Christians were codex "early adopters," I had assumed this came a little later than the...
I tried to post this earlier today, but apparently it did not work, so I re-send it now and apologize in advance if it produces duplicate posts on the list. ...
Hello again, Once again I thank y'all for giving me a chance to probe this thesis. I have several thoughts and would appreciate any comments or rebukes, as...
At 02:04 PM 7/20/2007, K L Noll wrote: [snip] ... I really like this suggestion. The emphasis on J the B in the gospels seems incompletely explained, and we...
... Stephen, Thanks for the correction. I'm traveling, and don't have my notes. And a quick Google didn't rescue my mistake. Bob Schacht University of Hawaii...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
