... Thank you, Mark, for this review. [SNIP] ... It seems to me that Jerome's view here mirrors a traditional Middle-Eastern (Semitic) way of thinking, whereby...
6536
rene joseph salm
rsalm@...
May 5, 1999 5:32 pm
I thought Xtk readers would be interested in a summary of the results of Nurit Feig's very informative article "Burial Caves at Nazareth" (Atiqot 10, 1990,...
6537
Philip B Lewis
phil@...
May 5, 1999 9:38 pm
Steve: I have something on the stove I'd like to put forward for comment: Proleptic Tradition(s), a work in process There are certain passages in our Gospels...
6538
stephen goranson
goranson@...
May 5, 1999 9:48 pm
The presentation on Nazareth archaeology on this list by Rene Joseph Salm is incompetent and dishonest. Some of the errors were detailed previosly; those...
6539
Jack Kilmon
jkilmon@...
May 5, 1999 9:57 pm
I think the archaeological evidence is clear that there was a village on this site dating at least to the early Roman period and habitation as far back as the...
6540
Jeffrey B. Gibson
jgibson000@...
May 5, 1999 10:08 pm
... You are not making a distinction here between a raising (a restoration of life) and a resurrection (a vindication of a pattern of faithfulness and an...
6541
Ian Hutchesson
mc2499@...
May 5, 1999 10:47 pm
Stephen, I wish you'd stop this tactic of yours, when you seem to have nothing more constructive to say, of rubbishing what someone says without you providing ...
6542
Mark Goodacre
M.S.GOODACRE@...
May 6, 1999 2:42 pm
... As I understand it, the difficulty with the Jerome view is that it only arises later on where it is explicitly connected with the apologetic desire to ...
6543
Jon Peter
jnp@...
May 6, 1999 5:05 pm
Am trying to determine the sense of the idiom 'sky and earth' in exegesis of GThom Saying 12: (12) The disciples said to Jesus, "We know that you will depart...
6544
Jan Sammer
sammer@...
May 6, 1999 5:30 pm
... earth' in exegesis of ... depart from us. Who ... Ya'akov the ... being." ... earth *being created ... priest-kingship. -- i.e., God ... But He is ... ...
6545
rene joseph salm
rsalm@...
May 6, 1999 6:43 pm
... The evidence is clearly against you on this one, Stephen. In fact, it seems to me that all you have are unsubstantiable allegations and conclusions. But...
6546
Jack Kilmon
jkilmon@...
May 6, 1999 6:49 pm
Steve: I will review the archaeological evidence again, including the new dig in Nazareth to assess your position. Nazareth is not a sacred cow with me....
6547
Tom Simms
tsimms@...
May 6, 1999 10:28 pm
... [... snip ... noted ...] Jack - This issue hit me in the 1980's in two ways, archaeological evidence there was naught there and the idea of Jesus the...
6548
Jon Peter
jnp@...
May 7, 1999 12:17 am
... Thanks for the memory jogger, Jan. That concept is indeed in Scripture. Gen 18.28 Abraham haggles with God over how many righteous men must be found in...
6549
joseph baxter
joseph@...
May 7, 1999 6:39 am
Thanks, Mark, for your thoughtful review. For my money, James 3: 3-12 is one of the great teachings of Christianity, right up there with the greatest...
6550
joseph baxter
joseph@...
May 7, 1999 6:54 am
There is a tradition within Judaism--for which someone else may find it easier to supply the references than I can at the moment--according to which the only...
6551
Jack Kilmon
jkilmon@...
May 7, 1999 8:18 am
... We have to rely on the archaeological evidence alone since the lack of any mention of Nazareth in Jesus' time or prior in no way suggests the village was...
6552
Tom Simms
tsimms@...
May 7, 1999 11:52 am
No need to double post, Jack (The copy is half a K larger than the message to me. You wasted 3 1/2 K.) You might check your SetUp... Tom ... Return-Path:...
6553
Tom Simms
tsimms@...
May 7, 1999 12:37 pm
... Where are the homes? 3-400 people need more than a few tombs. BTW, if you're talking archaeology, who was Solomon? ... Tom Simms ...
6554
Jack Kilmon
jkilmon@...
May 7, 1999 8:17 pm
... OK..Iron II (900-600 BCE). I just got my latest BAR and there is a brief article on page 14 on the archaeology of Nazareth. Give it a read. Jack -- ...
6555
Tom Simms
tsimms@...
May 7, 1999 11:00 pm
... I stopped subscribing and only get ot other's Web gear on occasion. Who's is it by and what do they say... Tom...
6556
BobSchacht@...
May 8, 1999 12:27 am
In a message dated 5/5/99 7:02:41 AM US Mountain Standard Time, ... HREF="mailto:M.S.Goodacre@...">M.S.Goodacre@... </A> ... ... Thanks, Mark! It...
6557
BobSchacht@...
May 8, 1999 12:28 am
In a message dated 5/5/99 2:57:37 PM US Mountain Standard Time, ... Horsley agrees that there was a substantial settlement at Nazareth during the first...
6558
BobSchacht@...
May 8, 1999 12:28 am
Now this is the kind of point and counterpoint from which one can learn. My thanks to both of you. Bob In a message dated 5/5/99 3:08:27 PM US Mountain...
6559
BobSchacht@...
May 8, 1999 12:33 am
In a message dated 5/5/99 3:47:10 PM US Mountain Standard Time, ... This kind of invective, from both of you, does not do credit to either of you. Ad hominem...
6560
rene joseph salm
rsalm@...
May 8, 1999 3:53 am
Jack, you really should bring yourself up to speed regarding Nazareth if you want to contribute to this discussion. We've already gone through the Pfann and...
6561
Ramon Souza Garcia
monjudas@...
May 8, 1999 5:04 am
Dear scholars, what is the MAINSTREAM position on James' relations to Jesus? Was he brother (sibling), cousin, or stepbrother? What is the consensus view? Or...
6562
Tom Simms
tsimms@...
May 8, 1999 2:22 pm
Rene Thank you for the Compleat Nazareth - I hope you check the archives and see this. Listers, you might alert Rene privately there is a post from me, so he...
6563
Tom Simms
tsimms@...
May 8, 1999 2:22 pm
... [... snip ... noted ...] ... Bob stands on his pretences. He has to, his girdle's too tight. Stephen condemned himself out of his own mouth. Ian simply...
6564
Jack Kilmon
jkilmon@...
May 8, 1999 2:53 pm
... No, I meant habitation in its earlieat development. In the bronze to iron age and before what some interpreters classify as its "refounding" as a village...
