... It is still virtually dead among those OT scholars who are not members of the Copenhagen School or, on the other end of the spectrum, Jewish and Christian...
4400
Antonio Jerez
antonio.jerez@...
Jan 3, 1999 11:49 pm
So the essenes where more radical than Jesus and the early Christians in at least one aspect- they cathegorically reputiated slavery in any form. I didn't know...
4401
Antonio Jerez
antonio.jerez@...
Jan 3, 1999 11:49 pm
... I just finished reading Dominic Crossan's "The birth of Christianity". On page 26-29 Crossan has some not very positive words to say about Meier's habit of...
4402
Ian Hutchesson
mc2499@...
Jan 4, 1999 12:06 am
... While Stephen's statement here seems true to me, there is a restricted situation that is directly euqivalent to the Synoptic problem if one cared to...
4403
Ian Hutchesson
mc2499@...
Jan 4, 1999 12:10 am
... This was not at all an intelligent post of yours, Stephen. Ian...
4404
Mike Grondin
mgrondin@...
Jan 4, 1999 12:32 am
By coincidence, I too have recently acquired a copy of Meier's two volumes, so I will be much interested in reading Bob's notes on it. I also obtained a copy...
4405
Bob Schacht
Robert.Schacht@...
Jan 4, 1999 1:26 am
... OK, I'll bite-- these "quite interesting results" are...? Bob Robert Schacht Northern Arizona University Robert.Schacht@... "This success of my...
4406
Jack Kilmon
jkilmon@...
Jan 4, 1999 1:53 am
... Philo also says that "Not a single slave is to be found among them" yet the scrolls talk about the treatment of slaves. We find the prohibition of slavery...
4407
Jim West
jwest@...
Jan 4, 1999 2:01 am
... Very cold. In any event, I don't know if you meant it as a slight or a compliment- but I take it as the latter. It is, to be sure, no dishonor to be...
4408
Jack Kilmon
jkilmon@...
Jan 4, 1999 2:01 am
... Really? I'm intrigued. Care to share? Jack -- ______________________________________________ taybutheh d'maran yeshua masheecha am kulkon Jack Kilmon ...
4409
Bob Schacht
Robert.Schacht@...
Jan 4, 1999 2:43 am
... Jim, OK, you've changed what I wrote in two important ways: 1. "...the *old* JEDP theory...." I suppose this means as formulated by Wellhausen 100 years...
4410
Bob Schacht
Robert.Schacht@...
Jan 4, 1999 3:53 am
... Interesting point; thanks! ... Well, of course, that is the standard defense of scholarly over-specialization. I was just trying to open up the doors and...
4411
Stephen C. Carlson
scarlson@...
Jan 4, 1999 3:53 am
... Ian, there are no stupid questions, only stupid answers. Aside from a typo, which may have made things unclear to you (I meant "Is it" not "It is), I was...
4412
Stephen C. Carlson
scarlson@...
Jan 4, 1999 4:11 am
... I meant neither, except to be humorous. I would agree, of course, that there's no dishonor to be associated with the Copenhagen School. Whether they...
4413
Stephen C. Carlson
scarlson@...
Jan 4, 1999 4:22 am
... Bob, both these passges, taken alone, are not sufficient by themselves to establish any kind of a literary as opposed to oral relationships between them....
4414
William
wm@...
Jan 4, 1999 4:26 am
Gentlemen, William's Hypothesis sets forth my solution to the synoptic problem. We would you please review and respond. Wm. G. Pinard ... Unto Thee In Order, ...
4415
Jack Kilmon
jkilmon@...
Jan 4, 1999 4:47 am
... This is one of the areas that I have to disagree with the JS. Their reasoning for voting black on the Lukan form of the LP while voting pink for the...
4416
Weasel
davjones@...
Jan 4, 1999 5:01 am
Jack Kilmon wrote: snip . . . ... Excuse me, but the JS preferred the Lukan form of the LP to the Matthean form precisely because it was the less embellished...
4417
Jim West
jwest@...
Jan 4, 1999 5:32 am
howdy. those interested in the so called "copenhagen" school and its theories regarding the Hebrew Bible should take a look at the Scandinavian Journal of the...
4418
Ian Hutchesson
mc2499@...
Jan 4, 1999 5:56 am
... Jack, I guess you're too busy assuming that CR was the product of a celibate sect (Essenes) to think clearly about the matter. If you were to write down ...
4419
Ian Hutchesson
mc2499@...
Jan 4, 1999 5:57 am
... When I had a quick look, Bob, I found that there was no way to attribute priority to any of the separate sources. They each had their own axes to grind and...
4420
Ian Hutchesson
mc2499@...
Jan 4, 1999 5:57 am
Bob responding to Jim's... ... The problem with the Documentary Hypothesis is that there is no one standard hypothesis: there are as many documentary...
4421
Ian Hutchesson
mc2499@...
Jan 4, 1999 6:08 am
... Sorry, Stephen. There have been numerous posts on lists I subscribe to that make rash statements about the so-called Copenhagen School. It seemed as though...
4422
Bob Schacht
Robert.Schacht@...
Jan 4, 1999 6:11 am
... Stephen, Thank you for helping me understand the state of the field in this manner. If I understand what you are saying correctly, the Ten Commandments...
4423
Tom Simms
tsimms@...
Jan 4, 1999 1:30 pm
... [... snip ... noted ...] ... Bob, you have just cited an example why Bible Scholars are in such bad odor with Palestinian Archaeologists such as Bill Dever...
4424
Bob Schacht
Robert.Schacht@...
Jan 4, 1999 2:17 pm
... Antonio, Is Crossan commenting on something Meier actually wrote about the virgin birth? Or is he attempting to launch a pre-emptive strike at something ...
4425
Mark Goodacre
M.S.GOODACRE@...
Jan 4, 1999 3:03 pm
I thought some of you might be interested in the following facility at FindMail. One can get a nice chronological listing (with links) of all one's postings...
4426
Mark Goodacre
M.S.GOODACRE@...
Jan 4, 1999 3:03 pm
There were several things of interest this Christmas in Britain. We had a programme called "Do You Believe In" featuring Gerd Luedemann talking about "the...
4427
Jack Kilmon
jkilmon@...
Jan 4, 1999 4:04 pm
... It doesn't mention it but when you read the document it does appear to present a community of celibate men. Vorlage to the effect of not being seduced by...
4428
Jim West
jwest@...
Jan 4, 1999 5:47 pm
... It can't be done Ian. There is no evidence at all linking the Essenes with either the site at Qumran or the scrolls deposited there. It is merely a leap...
