greeneto <tgreene@...> wrote:

Hi, Gary.

And now with the Earth impact craters you are ignoring both what you
already wrote previously as well as my direct response to what you
wrote. Here's my post:

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/creationism/message/5357

Gary, you know that you made the false statement

> Why do we have so many craters that show almost no
> erosion? There is not a single crater that has enough erosion to
> even indicate 20,000 years of wear.

and now you are obstinately refusing to acknowledge the fact that you
made this false statement and that I have directly addressed it.

Golly, is the Church of Christ in your neck of the woods giving
special YEC classes on "How To Be Totally Obstinate In Error" these
days?

The premise was yours. I simply showed factually that your premise
was completely wrong. Since I have personally visited any of these
craters, yes I do have to quote others about it. Are you now
pretending that we aren't supposed to cite independent authorities?
Typical YEC games!

Regards,
Todd S. Greene

   Dear Todd: A Major premise to support the articles sent by you was not given. I suggest that if you wnat to converse that you give data from which the conclusion may be derived as to age. Now, if you will give a Major premise that begins to explain the process by which erosion and age are correlated to the impacts I will happily respond. YOu have given nothing to respond to. Major premise please. Waiting--waiting--waiting!!!--Gary
http://www.geocities.com/Athens/Thebes/7755/


###### Gary Smith, 5/8/02 ######
> Dear Todd: The posts that you have sent me as well as the articles
> written by others make no attempt to establish a major premise.
> The material you sent me regarding craters had absolutely no major
> premise to establish their claim of age. Absolutely nothing---just
> one man qouting from another who himself gave no premise. You seem
> to think you establish your case by quoting from someone.
[snip]

  Post message: creationism@yahoogroups.com
  Online: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/creationism

Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service.