J.Michael Stracyzinski?! Yikes. Say what you will about the merits of the project itself, but Grant Morrison, writer of the best Batman comics of my lifetime,...
While I have a pretty open mind in general when it comes to spin-offs, sequels etc. by writers other than the original one (I try to judge them on a...
I won't be buying it, or reading it. And shame on all those people who are doing it. P ... I won't be buying it, or reading it. And shame on all those people...
... I know I am in a minority, but I always found Dr. Manhattan's part of the story to be interminable, the constant flashbacks and bland characterisation...
Kind of sad...but predictable. It¹s a pretty lukeward endorsement by Gibbons. ... Re: [alanmoore] Watchmen 2: they are real and... coming! Kind of sad...but...
I feel like theres a joke in here somewhere... How many DC creators does it take to try and make watchmen? -Victor DrawMoreInc.com ... From: Darren Shrubsole...
Here and in the related links http://dcu.blog.dccomics.com/2012/02/01/everyone%E2%80%99s-talkin%E2%80%99-about-%E2%80%9Cbefore-watchmen%E2%80%9D/ smok!...
I wrote a brief post about this, which might be of interest to the list. After thinking about this for a while, I believe that even if Moore and Gibbons did...
Nice post, Rodrigo. I'm conflicted on the issue. On the one hand, I admire Alan, and like to respect his wishes about the work. On the other hand, I like...
... Good questions, I'll try to explain. My definition of "something new" isn't really that strict. I believe Neil Gaiman taking elements of the DC Universe...
"I do feel bad to the extent this is trampling on Alan's moral rights here" If you really do feel bad, then I urge you not to buy the books. ... " I do feel...
I'm not convinced that this is trampling on his moral rights. I asked a bunch of questions about the facts earlier today, but didn't see an answer. Do you...
Moore¹s use of characters in LoEG and Lost Girls are mostly public domain characters....and so there¹s no question of legal infringement. There¹s no legal...
I could list here dozens of reasons justifying this prequel as I could also give the same number of reasons in defence of Moore. I don’t think this is a...
Here: http://comicbuzz.com/padraig-omealoid-talks-watchmen-and-before-watchmen smok! PS.: even if it will be written in Italian, I am also planning to post...
Thanks, Smoky! This is one of the reasons I didn't get around to answering some of the earlier stuff here about Watchmen 2, as I knew I was going to be doing...
First of all, Lenny (I can't do that thing you do with the raised E, so won't try), I was actually quoting what you'd said yourself, where you said, "I do...
That's a fantastically good and lucid piece, Eric. Thanks for taking the time to do it. P ... That's a fantastically good and lucid piece, Eric. Thanks for...
Pádraig - your words have cut through the reams of misinformed fan reaction, Beyond Watchmen (BW)creators' self-justification and alan moore-bashing, all of...
19386
Kevin
kevindh@...
Feb 3, 2012 9:17 pm
I think Erik Larson sums things up pretty well right out of the gate: "Corporations are going to exploit their IPs — that's what they do. If you thought DC...
Gosh! That's extraordinarily kind of you. Thank you very much. ... Gosh! That's extraordinarily kind of you. Thank you very much. From: Andrew Edwards...
Well, we are all aware about the Watchmen prequels.... I was wondering... what's about V for Vendetta? So, I asked the question to David Lloyd. You can read...
Hi Padraig, my position will be pretty similar to your one. I will not buy them, I will not read them, I will not support this operation in any way. I prefer...
I'll confess to being spontaneously excited about the idea of Watchmen prequels, but the more one reads the output of defenders of the project the more...
