You do it again below. My comment was that wsm/spgb/wic ... literature ... between the ... that. Wherein lies the difference? In the nature of administration...
... like me ... force even ... your ... we will ... Why did the state come into being? It is precisely to provide class society with the arms to protect...
PETER: This you have (repeatedly) failed to demonstate for your system. I asked you to show how your system would solve even the the most simple problem of...
RAYS: Your "subjective" insistence leads to your rapid demise, as evidenced earlier - just the same as before. PETER: As we have clearly seen, they do *not*...
Byron: I am sure that Graham will have more than an adequate answer for you .. You can check out the SPGB site anytime you want and get an answer => What...
... Peter may be familiar with Maslow and the "Hierarchy of needs". Others here may not be. It gives a pretty clear explanation of this concept in graphical...
... Yes, there is the spgb/wsm/wic contradiction. Socialism claims to be voluntary yet cannot brook any competition. So which is it, Graham? Is socialism...
ROBIN: Peter, stop playing silly buggers. I have already given you a practical example of how precisely opportunity costs could be ascertained and economic...
... JOHN: Yes, there is the spgb/wsm/wic contradiction. Socialism claims to be voluntary yet cannot brook any competition. So which is it, Graham? Is...
Robin and Moderaters: It should be obvious by now that anybody that refuses to answer the points that Robin has made deserves no further consideration. Just...
... My goodness Ray, you got something right. Or at least almost right. There is no such thing as inherent value except when it applies to yourself, or Peter,...
Byron: ATTENTION: Arminius or Torgun. Please jettison Peter/Derek from the forum! => The real problem, of course, is that Byron has no answers to his critics....
GRAHAM: Socialism/communism entails the end of generalised commodity production. Such a system (where useful items possessing exchange value are bought and...
CJ: But do [the libertarians] imagine doing away with the state? McD at least tacitly acknowledges the need for force to protect his class interest => I doubt...
JOHN HENRY: As the SPGB says, socialists have no problem with me forming a voluntary capitalist society. => And capitalism, being a system of voluntary social...
JOHN: My comment was that wsm/spgb/wic socialists claim to believe in the absence of government. Your literature contradicts this since I fail to see any...
CJ: Only private ownership of wealth can only be coercive; to own land for example means soil is not available for others to cultivate food to live. If you...
PETER: Nothing in Robin's emails showed how people in a moneyless economy could tell at a a glance what the opportunity costs of any two products picked at...
Hi Byron ... the points that Robin has made deserves no further consideration. Just remember that Peter Kidson once presented himself as Derek Piston. The...
JOHN: Yes, there is the spgb/wsm/wic contradiction. Socialism claims to be voluntary yet cannot brook any competition. So which is it, Graham? Is socialism...
RAYS: You stipulate firstly, that there is "no such thing as inherent worth/value" between the spuds/gems, ... PETER: This is just incoherent. RAYS: Since...
Peter, I have already asked you to restrict the number of postings you make daily to 3 as per the rules of the forum. You have 9 posts so far today and this...
... Is this a new rule? I have no problem with it but it is the first I've heard of it. I am sure I have violated it from time to time but will be more careful...
... I agree that a stateless world is harder to imagine than a four-footed bird, and I see no motion toward a lesser state In bush's America as in Friedman's...
... CJ: Will you create your capitalism with the people who want it and their property or will you plunder from others and force them to live under capitalism?...
Capitalism is based on minority ownership of the means of production and distribution. So Peter and John have to sell their idea of socialism. Maybe it will go...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
