To: CGC Cc: Synoptic, WSW On: Chinese Legal History: Jacob and the Kang Gau From: Bruce One of the documents often relied on in writing the history of Chinese...
Dave Gentile wrote: "Dave Inglis has been trying out some different mathematical approaches and we've been looking at the results. I'll spare everyone the...
To: Synoptic Cc: GPG; WSW; CGC In Response To: Dave Inglis From: Bruce At the end of a statistical report (which as Dave Gentile noted, suppressed information...
... David, Indeed. This is why I prefer the term "Double Tradition". ... You won't find much disagreement here. ... You have assumed that the latter was all...
... Dave, You and Mark may make this supposition, but you'd both be wrong. Have you ever analysed the Double Tradition (the material common to Matthew and Luke...
David, Since Mt used 90% of Mk while Lk used only 60%, your item number 2 can be explained this way: Mt reworked his sources less than Lk, and the M...
I've read disagreement over whether it is fair to characterize Q as a sayings source (or, rather, the double tradition as exclusively containing sayings...
To: GPG Cc: Synoptic In Response To: Chuck Jones On: Mt and Lk use of Mk From: Bruce CHUCK: Since Mt used 90% of Mk while Lk used only 60%, . . . BRUCE:...
I want to respond to each of the previous posts in this thread, but not at the moment. So for now I'll just take the last response first. Chuck, The scenario...
Dave, When I say "'Q' material" I always try to put the "Q" in scare quotes, but maybe the quote marks are interpreted differently, and thus that intended...
To: Synoptic Cc: WSW In Response To: Dave G On: Hypotheses vs Guess From: Bruce Couldn't we use some agreed nomenclature in this area? DAVE: Also, if the only...
I can understand that the authors of the study may well wish to wait till the whole study is published before releasing specific details, but it would be...
David Mealand
D.Mealand@...
May 12, 2009 9:41 am
1893
... Bruce, "irrefutably"? Perhaps someone should have pointed this out to Professor Goulder, who finds traces of this section of Mark elsewhere in Luke...
All the details (for my investigation) can be found here: http://www.davegentile.com/synoptics/main.html Dave I is using the same data and categories and is...
BRUCE: I think a little better than Dave here seems to of statistics; a good statistical result, at least in some cases, comes complete with a label as to its...
Ron Price: You and Mark may make this supposition, but you'd both be wrong. Have you ever analysed the Double Tradition (the material common to Matthew and...
David Mealand wrote: "I can understand that the authors of the study may well wish to wait till the whole study is published before releasing specific details,...
Just one addition to this. I think in the process of developing the study and refining the method we certainly did see some odd results. These were used to...
To: Synoptic Cc: GPG In Response To: Ron Price On: The Lukan Great Omission From: Bruce Date: 13 May 2009 I had pointed out that Streeter (The Four Gospels,...
... Dave, Perhaps the key to understanding your proposal is in this earlier statement of yours. But it baffles me. Are you referring here to the whole of the ...
Thanks to the two Davids for the clarifications on their statistical methods, and for the info on where the rest of it is to be found. I look forward to going...
David Mealand
D.Mealand@...
May 13, 2009 9:51 am
1902
To: Synoptic Cc: GPG In Response To: Ron Price ap Dave Gentile On: Lukan Accuracy From: Bruce I confess I am not up on Dave's recent proposals in sufficient...
What strikes me here is that the main objection to Q is that no extant copy exists, so theories that don't need it are to be preferred. Here we have a copy...
Ron, Sometimes when we leave of a thread for a year or more, I still tend to assume everyone knows what I'm talking about. This is probably a poor assumption...
Bruce, I see that Streeter is available on-line, so I'll go do my homework and read it. But I will raise my previous objections (and perhaps Streeter answers...
Wow. Interrupting a transition line is hardly the same as interrupting a pericope. Lk would have known that the transitions were Mk's work, the pericope...
(Thanks for the tip that Streeter's book is online!) Bruce, Here is the passage in which Streeter introduces his theory that Lk had a mutilated copy of...
Dave, Thanks for the summary of your position. ... They are in your email to Synoptic-L dated 17 Dec 2007. If you have any difficulty getting hold of this, let...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
