... Since nobody answered I take it that a) nobody is interested in this or b) nobody has the time to answer or c) nobody knows any "major agreements in...
Wieland, I'm interested, but I come under your category (b); I am still checking my references to see whether I can get you a major, but doing so against ...
... This was discussed in E. P. Sanders, "The Argument from Order and the Relationship Between Matthew and Like," New Testament Studies 15 (1968-69): 249-61;...
I have been re-reading Sander's examples since Wieland sent that reminder earlier this evening (here). Neirynck (1973 ETL 49:784-815) has attempted to refute...
I am a bit too busy to comment on this interesting question at the moment, but let me recommend Jeffrey Peterson, "Order in the Double Tradition and the...
consistent corrections made to a text of Mark that pre-dated what we have today. SUV and META emendations to the text or Mark At several points in the text of...
... That a word does not appear elsewhere in GMark is a strange criterion for declaring that a verse or phrase which contains it is "questionable". Is...
... that ... narrative. ... text ... narrative. ... strange criterion ... it is ... that says that if he ... once? More ... only once that if ... In any...
Many times in the course of posting to this list I have encountered opposition to the overall assumption that there is a clearly discernable narrative ...
... I have read the article now and have to conclude that there are NO "major agreements in order" of Mt and Lk against Mk. Sanders lists four instances, all...
Jeffrey wrote: Curious isn't it, that anyone from a pro Petrine camp would interpolate Mk. 1:13b allegedly to make Mark more pro Petrine, but leave untouched ...
... and Lk ... from ... Like," New ... I have read the article now and have to conclude that there are NO "major agreements in order" of Mt and Lk against Mk. ...
... I read them. But I didn't buy your argument or your conclusions. ... Not properly cited? Lacking in scholarly form? I don't know how you can say this...
Jeffrey wrote: In any event, I suggest that you read the texts of Ps. 91, T.Iss. 7.7, T.Benj. 5:2, and T. Naph. 8.4 and then tell me whether your claim that...
... Rick, This is not how Ockham's razor cuts in this case: the lack of Matthew's and Luke's agreements in order against Mark only means that Mark is the ...
... Lieb Wieland: This is not exactly correct. Lk's citation of Isaias is not the identical word for word quote as is found in Mk. So, even this does not...
John C. Poirier wrote: This is not how Ockham's razor cuts in this case: the lack of Matthew's and Luke's agreements in order against Mark only means that Mark...
... Just for the record, I asked my question because I was unaware that I **had** any particular agenda, and was interested in knowing what this was perceived...
... I know all about it, but it's good to have it stated like this. ... No it doesn't. (See below.) ... That grammar school teacher (whether he's the one...
... I hardly think this is the case. But be that as it may, remember please that this is a scholarly list. So I should hardly be faulted for using here --...
... *raises hand*--- pick me, pick me- I know..... That said, I think it fair to say that most folk working in Synoptic studies would know right away what...
I believe the conclusion of that Mk was a source for both Mt and Lk is based on disagreement in passages common only to Mt and Lk, not on passages in the...
... I would expect active contributors to either know these references (to the Testaments of Issachar, Benjamin, and Naphtali, respectively) or know where to...
John C. Poirier wrote: That grammar school teacher (whether he’s the one named by E. A. Abbott or someone else) would be wrong. If A and C agree in order...
... The difficulty here is that you are invoking a proposed solution to the problem (that Mark and Q overlap) as part of your statement of the data. Mark-Q...
It seems apologies are in order. My memory is not as acute as all those on the list apparently. I studied with Dr James Charlesworth 2 years at Princeton...
... Not to beat a dead horse, or seem callous in the face of your apology, but the abbreviations Charlesworth used/uses are not "his". In any case, the...
And if you'd actually looked at the theme of "being with wild beasts and ministering angels" that appears and is prominent in T.Iss. 7.7, T.Benj. 5:2, and T....
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
