To: GPG Cc: Previous On: ARONSON 4rev From: Bruce Sorry, there were errors in the previously posted ARONSON 4 (LUKE) note (Moral: do not try to do philology...
To: Synoptic In Response To: Ron Price On: Lord's Prayer [different thread name] From: Bruce RON: I agree with Jack here. The use of "debts" for "sins" clearly...
To: GPG Cc: WSW, Synoptic On: ARONSON 1 From: Bruce In 1999, over there on the bookstore table next to the organic greeting cards, we had Marcus Borg: Jesus...
With apologies for cross posting. It's that time of year again when the Society of Biblical Literature's Annual Meeting is just around the corner (Nov. 21st -...
An interesting dissertation can be found here: <http://www.archive.org/details/TheSayingsOfJesusInTheParaen esisOfJames> "The Sayings of Jesus in the...
"Q as Hypothesis: A Study in Methodology" Francis Watson New Testament Studies (2009), 55:397-415 Abstract Arguments for the Q hypothesis have changed little...
Maurice Casey liberated a much-needed cat among the synoptic pigeons when he set out detailed evidence that an Aramaic source lay behind the 'Woes' ("An ...
In his "The Case against Q", pp. 165-69, Mark Goodacre argues that if the Minor Agreements were to be accepted as valid evidence that Luke knew Matthew, then...
Some of my previous arguments for the synoptic use of a sayings source do not necessarily apply to Luke. So I have now extended and clarified the arguments for...
To: GPG Cc: WSW; Synoptic, various In Response To: Dave I On: Lk 7:46 From: Bruce Dave asks about the meaning of three words omitted by Bezae in Lk 7:46. This ...
In Mk 1:2 par, both Mt and Lk do not have the Malachi quote. Both cite it later at Mt 11:10/Lk 7:27, but not here. Did they both omit it, because it is not...
What evidence is there (mss, patristic references, anything else) for the early existence of Luke chapters 1-3? To put it another way round, how far back in...
The longer I lurk on or contribute to online forums (all to do with the NT, as it happens), the more I get the impression that, however good the contributors...
Marcion wrote his gospel around 140 AD, and our two major sources for his text are Tertullian: 'Against Marcion' (207-208 AD), and Epiphanius: 'Panarion,...
To: Synoptic On: Matthew and Mark From: Bruce With its 2009 PB publication by SBL, Delbert Burkett's 2004 study "Rethinking the Gospel Sources v2: The Unity...
Is anyone familiar with Matthias Klinghardt, "The Marcionite Gospel and the Synoptic: A New Suggestion," in which he ties Marcion into the synoptic problem? I...
Just to bring the synoptic list up to date with some of the rest of the discussion. We are also trying to figure out Epiphiniaus's Luke. One explanation, and...
Just to let you all know that I have removed the message from the archive and banned the author. Sorry that sometimes these things get through. Best wishes,...
Thank you Mark. I fully agree. But now the big question. Who is right? The Catholic - Luther appraisal of Simon Peter ed. Raymond or Th. Weeden's theory of...
... https://secure.aidcvt.com/sbl/ProdDetails.asp?ID=064501P&PG=1&Type=BL&PCS=SBL Stephen Carlson -- Stephen C. Carlson Ph.D. student, Religion, Duke...
The latest instantiation of the Review of Biblical Literature ... Stephen Carlson -- Stephen C. Carlson Ph.D. student, Religion, Duke University Author of The...
Has anyone here taught courses on 1 Peter? If so, I'd be grateful to know what books you used in teaching the course and to see the syllabi you drew up for...
One of the curious points made by Tertullian is that Marcion erased from his gospel passages that we do not see in canonical Luke. Instead, the passages ...
Klinghardt's solution (the article) is available free at ingentaconnect.com. It was published in Novum Testamentum, 50.1, 2008. It is a pdf download. Dennis...
I've discovered that I can express this entire argument with no mathematics at all. This may be a good thing since some may not like their ancient Greek mixed...
I would take it as a working hypothesis that Thomas had layers. It also seems that there are late changes to the gospel of Luke that are more than typical...
Dave, I may not have stated my point about the discovery of Thomas clearly. Thomas matters in this discussion not because we have a new set of materials...
To: Synoptic Cc: GPG In Response To: Chuck Jones On: Outside Documents From: Bruce CHUCK: . . . documents that are included or mentioned in the NT that are no...
In examining the proposed "L" we seem to have found a number of different things. In some cases Luke does seem to depend on non-canonicals. 14:1-6 seems to...
Having problems with message search?
