Kevin Johnson asks about the the similarities and differences between Q and the Gospel of Thomas? This is a very big question, and I'm not sure where to begin...
Mark Goodacre, who is "not yet fully persuaded of the existence of Q" inquires about my argument on p. 41 on Luke's general failure to reproduce features of...
First of all I would like to thank Mark Goodacre and Stephen Carlson for hosting the seminar and Prof. Kloppenborg Verbin for participating in it. I am...
Dear John As someone who is not yet fully persuaded of the existence of Q, I very much enjoyed your clear and helpful discussion of "Q and the Synoptic...
Wieland Willker asks about the disappearance of Q. First, is its "disappearance" an argument against Q. Hardly. We know that various other documents...
Thanks to Mark for setting up this interesting seminar and to Dr. Kloppenborg for taking the time to answer. My question is short but probably the answer is...
Dr. Kloppenborg Verbin, I am greatly enjoying reading _Excavating Q_ and want to add my voice to those who have already expressed their appreciation for your...
Sukie Curtis picks up my comments to Dean Peilstick regarding Crossan's Common Sayings Tradition. There are, I think, some differences between the approaches...
I would like to thank Dr. Hindley for his kind words about THE FORMATION OF Q, and especially for seeing what some readers did not, namely that I tried to...
Professor Kloppenborg-Verbin, While I have not read extensively from the large selection of books devoted to the synoptic problem and the analysis of "Q", I...
Ken Olson's question raises an extremely difficult question, and one for which I think we are only beginning to have the answers (or at least, some answers). ...
Dr. Kloppenborg Verbin, My next question is about Luke's ordering of the Q material. In _Excavating Q_ you state that those cases where we can establish Luke's...
Dr. Dean Pielstick writes, ".I am working on a document for Westar regarding Crossan's Common Sayings Tradition and would like to hear your thoughts on CST as...
Greetings...I am working on a document for Westar regarding Crossan's Common Sayings Tradition and would like to hear your thoughts on CST as the (a?) source...
Jeff Peterson says some very nice things about my discussion of the theological implications of the Synoptic Problem, for which I am appreciative, and then...
To Michael Goulder: Michael raises questions having more to do with the IQP than with ExQ, though I touch on issues of reconstruction in the second chapter of...
Brian McCarthy asks "Does your work on Q presuppose that Jesus taught publicly in Greek?" but also asks about the relation of the Jesus Seminar to my work on ...
Dear Prof. K-V Does your work on Q presuppose that Jesus taught publicly in Greek? [As far as I know this is a position of the JS, against the consensus of...
Dr. Olson asks an important question concerning the extent of Q: "Now, given that Mark and Q overlapped, and that Luke might have omitted pericopes from Q, how...
Dear John, Since my own research interests in the NT are in social analysis, the sections of *ExQ* that interested me most were those dealing with social...
Hello John, greetings from Finland. I find it great that you and Mark Goodacre have organized an event like this. Thank you! I just joined in and have not even...
Dr. Kloppenborg Verbin, Thank you very much for taking the time to answer our questions. My question has to do with the original extent of Q. In _Excavating...
First of all, I would like to thank Stephen (if I may) for his kind words on ExQ. I did spend a lot of time on chap. 6 on the history of the SynProb, most...
Dear Prof. Kloppenborg Verbin, Thank you very much for agreeing to participate in this seminar discussion your most recent book. There is much to commend in...
In about half of the Q words, Matthew and Luke concur (QC words), and in half they disagree (QD). When the IQP has to decide the Q form behind the QD words, it...
October 23, 2000 A briefer response to James Warren. James Warren notes that while the 2 Document Hypothesis has been a standard explanatory model for years,...
Although the Q material common to Luke and Matthew has been out in the open air for decades, its existence and effect on traditional mainline "Bible Study" has...
October 23, 2000 First of all, I would like to thank Mark Goodacre for the trouble he has gone to organize this on-line seminar, and for his generosity in...
I'd like to use chair's privilege of asking the first question in this on-line seminar, if I may. But before that I'd like to thank Professor Kloppenborg...
Welcome to the on-line seminar with John Kloppenborg Verbin on _Excavating Q_. You are receiving this preliminary message because you are one of the 311...
