PR555: 20mph speed limits have bigger crashes than 30mph speed limits

news: for immediate release

With a proposal for 20mph speed limits in the news today, Safe Speed accuses
the proposers of ignoring the evidence.

Latest national figures indicate that average accident severity is far higher
in 20mph zones than in 30mph zones.

* In 20mph zones in 2006 17% of injury crashes were fatal or serious
* In 30mph zones in 2006 13% of injury crashes were fatal or serious [1]

What these figures tell us:

* The authorities are ignoring important road safety evidence by pressing on
without explaining the figures.

* The simple 'a lower speed limit lowers crash severity' is proved false.
(Other factors must be considered.)

What these figures DO NOT tell us:

* Changing the speed limit from 30mph to 20mph makes crashes worse. (we might,
for example, have applied 20mph zones ONLY to exceptionally dangerous places.)

* Anything about changes to the numbers of crashes

Paul Smith, founder of SafeSpeed.org.uk, said: "The authorities are ignoring
their own evidence. Instead they are working on the basis of belief. No more
20mph zones should be rolled out until the figures are fully explained."

"The figures destroy the general argument that driving slower means smaller
crashes. Obviously the national picture is telling us something completely
different. In 20mph zones we're having worse crashes than in 30mph zones."

"We're shifting the balance from responsibility to regulation and it simply
does not work. We need more responsibility, not more regulation."

"Modern road safety policies haven't proved effective. Neither road deaths nor
hospitalisations have fallen as expected - and road safety policy must take the
blame."

<ends>

Notes for editors
=================

Previous PRs:

The dangerous 20mph zone mystery:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/SafeSpeedPR/message/281

[1] Calculated from Table 4, RCGB 2006 DfT national figures.
http://www.dft.gov.uk/172974/173025/221412/221549/227755/285672/WebTables120.xls

Safe Speed spreadsheet showing the simple calculations:
http://www.safespeed.org.uk/pr555.xls



Contact Safe Speed
================

description: Safe Speed road safety campaign
web: http://www.safespeed.org.uk
email: psmith@...
temp telephone: 01379 741374
mobile: 07799 045553

Location: usually North Scotland, presently Norfolk

To be added to our PR distribution list send an email to
psmith@...

Recent press releases (since November 2004) are automatically and immediately
uploaded to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/SafeSpeedPR

Recent photo of Paul Smith:
http://www.safespeed.org.uk/ps004.jpg

=================================================================
Contact: temp telephone: 01379 741374 (Paul Smith is in Norfolk.)
=================================================================