Date:01/11/2006 URL: http://www.thehindu.com/2006/11/01/stories/2006110104991100.htm Opinion - News Analysis Promoting open access to research Stevan Harnad ...
Hello, This seems to be yet another case of plagiarism. Several sentences from Anup Saikia's 2002 article 'Global processes and local concerns: Bangladeshi...
Hello, This email message is a notification to let you know that a file has been uploaded to the Files area of the ResearchEthics group. File : /Sakia's...
ResearchEthics@yahoog...
Dec 26, 2006 4:13 am
111
I have uploaded this as file on the ResearchEthics site and am also forwarding it. Sumi anup saikia <anmsaikia@...> wrote: Date: 25 Dec 2006...
Anup, I am sorry, the forwarded mail does not maintain the table, which makes comparison much easier. However, the table is in the file: Sakia's work...
madam, thank you, and i agree with your assessment, its not an error of having left out quotation marks & the citation, I will send off the hard copies to the...
Anup, Sumi and other friends, Minerva Calcutta brought out my Book 'Legislative Control over Public Administration long back in 1993. I found in google search...
amiya chaudhuri
amiya_chaudhuri@...
Dec 26, 2006 6:46 pm
115
Dear sumi, Archana should be punished. The authorities of the Fulbright scholarship givers are to be intimated the degree of dishonestry and moth eaten...
amiya chaudhuri
amiya_chaudhuri@...
Dec 26, 2006 6:53 pm
116
Dear All, The plagiarism of Dr. Saikia's article is shocking and depressing as well. I personally feel, that young researchers are most vulnerable to...
Hello, I am pasting below copies of some recent mails on this. Sumi ... 9th Jan AnupSaikia to Archana Upadhyay i do not understand what and how 'corrective...
Anup Saikia, You have done a wrong and wanted to befool the innocent. And again you are trying to argue. You should be ashamed and requested to stop making...
amiya chaudhuri
amiya_chaudhuri@...
Jan 9, 2007 6:01 am
119
Hello Prof. Choudhuri, Have you got the names mixed up, here? It was Saikia's work that has been plagiarised by Archana Upadhyay! Sumi...
Sumi and Friends, I am absolutely sorry to confuse. I put my appology to Anup saikkia. In fact in the morning I just made a cursory glance. I should have been...
amiya chaudhuri
amiya_chaudhuri@...
Jan 9, 2007 10:00 am
121
archana upadhyay has written to the editor EPW stating that an "unintentional error" was made... can use of 22 words ditto be termed 'unintentional'... more...
Without doubt, Archana Upadhyay has reproduced material from Dr Saikia's paper, mostly verbatim, but at times through minor paraphrasing. Using either of these...
I am convinced that it is not an over sight. Saikia deserves a public apology. We should not allow plagiarism. It has become a menace. I wish to remind all of...
apurba baruah
akbaruah@...
Feb 3, 2007 4:06 am
124
Apurba, This is not confined to Northeast India only. Not to speak of the writers- plagiarists even the renouned publisher just changing a word of the Title...
amiya chaudhuri
amiya_chaudhuri@...
Feb 5, 2007 6:28 pm
125
Sorry for the mistake. Wiley and son brought out the book without the original publisher and my consent amiya. ... the ... ...
amiya chaudhuri
amiya_chaudhuri@...
Feb 6, 2007 7:38 am
126
This is really stunning. The Committee members are scientists and academics of high repute. The Commerce Ministry should immediately disband the Committee and...
Yes Rajesh, and it is very easy for this committee to blame it on the subgroup that drafted the report! The Mashelkar report would certainly not have been...
Date:03/03/2007 URL: http://www.thehindu.com/2007/03/03/stories/2007030303591100.htm Opinion - News Analysis A bit of unacknowledged borrowing At a time...
The difficulty is that the Finance Minister does not write the script of the budget. The minister with their penchant for media glare only does not apply their...
amiya chaudhuri
amiya_chaudhuri@...
Mar 3, 2007 6:04 am
131
dear all, you might want to take a look at Lou Bloomfield's web site (Prof. Bloomfield,Physics Dept., University of Virginia) which provides a handy free...
Dear All, Jokes apart, it is frustrating to see plagiarism at the highest rung of democratic system. I do not feel it is a part of a lapse on the part of an...
Hello Meghana, Yes, I think this is arrogance not ignorance. We have many examples of such plagiarism (my own work and and that of others) by Govt. and its ...
Dear All, Surely I was joking in reference to the YesMinister bureaucrats. Really I share your sentiment and concerns. It's not a bad idea to organise a...
amiya chaudhuri
amiya_chaudhuri@...
Mar 5, 2007 7:12 am
135
Dear All I quite agree with Meghna Kelkar.That bureaucrats, who so gleefully try to apply all kinds of existing or even extinct rules and principles on the...
Dear Sumi, I have seen books of different authors at different points of time the same title with a different story by different writers. Now you are citing...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
