http://thetyee.ca/Views/2008/04/30/TruthAndAbuse/

Truth and Native Abuse
How one man's wild claims threaten success of Truth and Reconciliation.

By Terry Glavin
Published: April 30, 2008
TheTyee.ca

When Noam Chomsky says Canada's famously defrocked United Church minister
Kevin Annett is "more deserving of the Nobel Peace Prize than many who have
received it in the past," you can take his word for it if you want. And if
you like, you can believe Nobel Peace Prize winner Mairead Corrigan-Maguire
of the Belfast Peace People when she calls Annett "a courageous and
inspiring man."

It's important to be fair, and to allow that sometimes people say things
without really knowing what they're talking about and they might one day
regret the things they've said.

But if you do believe these things, I'm afraid there are quite a few more
things you are going to have to believe, because you can't have it both
ways. If Kevin Annett really is prize-worthy and courageous, you will also
have to believe this:

-One of Canada's most respected First Nations' leaders is trafficking in
children from Northern British Columbia in a profitable pedophilia ring
that's run out of the West Hastings Street premises of the swish Vancouver
Club. His clients are Vancouver judges, politicians, and church leaders.

-Back in the 1930s, a team of German doctors arrived at the Kuper Island
Indian residential school and began conducting strange medical experiments
on the children. Employing large hypodermic needles, they injected some
sort of toxin directly into the chests of the school's young inmates, and
several were killed as a result.

-As recently as the 1950s and 1960s, aboriginal children at a Vancouver
Island medical research facility were tortured with electrodes implanted in
their skulls. At least one child was beaten to death with a whip fitted
with razors.

-At the Hobbema and Saddle Lake Indian residential schools in Alberta,
children were incinerated in furnaces. At St. Anne's Indian residential
school in Fort Albany, Ontario, children were executed in an electric
chair. At McGill University in Montreal, there is a mass grave containing
the bodies of aboriginal children killed in experiments undertaken by the
Central Intelligence Agency's top-secret MK-ULTRA program.

These are just a few of the stories Annett has been circulating since the
early 1990s. He has failed to produce a shred of evidence. RCMP
investigators who have looked into Annett's allegations always come up
empty. Some of these stories the RCMP hasn't investigated because nobody's
reported them, for reasons Annett explains as a distrust of the police.

'Eagle Strong Voice' and his followers

If you think this sort of thing is courageous to the point of being worthy
of the Nobel Prize, then you may be happy to know that Annett is busy with
another one of his crusades against church and state, with new claims about
a network of mass graves across Canada containing the remains of perhaps
thousands of aboriginal children, murdered by priests and nuns.

You might also be pleased to know that Annett is back with a new name (he
has lately taken to calling himself Eagle Strong Voice) and his followers
have established a new group, called the Friends and Relatives of the
Disappeared, and they're off on a "wave of church occupations" across
Canada.

Their routine is to show up with the media in tow, and then issue eviction
notices, and then submit unanswerable demands that the churches confess to
the mass graves they've been hiding. And then they demand that the churches
return the remains of the children they've killed to the tribes they came
from.

It all started in the early 1990s, when Annett was a promising but
problematic novice minister whose first assignment was to serve the
dwindling, white working-class congregation of St. Andrew's in the mill
town of Port Alberni. It wasn't long before senior United Church officials
discovered to their dismay that Annett was turning his Sunday services into
something resembling a series of cathartic, guerilla-theatre testimonials
about Satanic ritual abuse. The long and short of it is the United Church
put its foot down. Its version of events is a matter of public record.

Annett's version appears in his self-published Hidden from History: The
Canadian Holocaust, his autobiographical Love and Death in the Valley, and
his recently-released, 110-minute autobiographical documentary,
Unrepentant: Kevin Annett and Canada's Genocide.

If you like, you can believe that the reason 10 Canadian publishers turned
down Annett's first book, and the reason why his second book appears under
the imprint of 1st Books Library, a vanity press in Bloomington, Indiana,
and the reason his documentary was also produced in the United States, is
that the powers that be in Canada are determined to conceal their terrible
crimes.

Or, you might instead take into account the fact that Annett's stories are
the subject of Canadian court injunctions claiming libel and defamation.
Annett has responded to these legal admonitions by pleading with Amnesty
International for adoption as a "prisoner of conscience." Amnesty has
declined to oblige him.

Journalists compound the harm

Still, Annett is interviewed sympathetically on CBC's As It Happens, and it
is commonplace for journalists to report Annett's claims unchallenged, no
matter how bizarre, and without first inquiring into his history of
allegation-making. His documentary film Unrepentant has earned favourable
reviews in such "progressive" Canadian journals as Briarpatch. It has won
awards at independent film festivals in New York and Los Angeles.

This matters.

It matters because the story of secret residential-school mass graves is an
urban legend.

For years, RCMP investigators have been chasing down these stories and they
always come up with nothing. But they persist, like the alligators in New
York's sewers.

It matters because the thousands of aboriginal people who really did suffer
unspeakable torment in residential schools deserve something rather more
from us than our complicity in the act of dumping their very real suffering
down a rabbit hole into the same parallel universe where you'll find alien
abductions, Masonic plots, crop circles, and 9-11 conspiracies.

It matters for lots of reasons.

Annett enjoys the backing of not a single representative tribal
organization, and in early April, when he released what he claims is a list
of the locations of 28 mass graves of children who died in church-run
residential schools, he also announced the formation of the "International
Human Rights Tribunal into Genocide in Canada" to carry out its own
investigations.

At risk, Truth and Reconciliation

Meanwhile, after a generation of bitter and hard-fought struggle, the
Assembly of First Nations, the Canadian churches that ran the schools and
the federal government have embarked upon a $2 billion settlement process
that includes the Indian Residential Schools Truth and Reconciliation
Commission.

On April 28, Justice Harry S. LaForme, a judge on the Ontario Appeals Court
and a member of the Mississauga Nation, was appointed its chairman. The
commission, inspired by the post-apartheid stabilization process in South
Africa, will soon begin its hearings.

Among ordinary Canadians, there already exists a perfectly understandable
but stubborn reluctance to believe the heart-rending truth about what
actually did happen in some of those institutions. The abuse and the
cruelty was sometimes almost beyond belief. And there is no shortage of
pundits in this country who are all too eager to encourage that tendency to
disbelieve the survivors' stories.

If the Truth and Reconciliation Commission gets dragged into the strange,
alternative reality where Annett and his followers thrive, the commission's
purpose could be easily defeated. If that happens, we will have lost an
historic opportunity to see justice properly done in finally turning the
page on one of the darkest and most disgraceful chapters in Canadian
history.

Blind alleys

This matters.

It matters because Annett has alleged that perhaps "hundreds" of tiny
corpses are buried in a mass grave behind a former United Church
residential school building situated on Tseshaht reserve land, near Port
Alberni -- and now I want you to stop reading this for a moment and try to
imagine what it would be like to be a Tseshaht person reading that same
sentence. Tseshaht Chief Coun. Les Sam says he can't imagine what Annett is
taking about.

It matters because at Kuper Island, where the Penelakut people have lived
from time out of mind, Annett has reported unmarked graves associated with
murders at the Catholic residential school that once operated there.
Islander Robert Sam, a Penelakut elder who attended the residential school,
says he'd heard stories about school children who drowned trying to swim
away from the school, but no, certainly nothing about these graves.

Annett and his followers have alleged there are skeletons "between the
walls" and under the foundations of buildings at Alert Bay, on Cormorant
Island. Namgis tribal administrator George Speck says "no one has a clue"
what would make Annett say these things. At Meares Island, Annett says
corpses of schoolchildren were stored in the basement of a residential
school building, and the bodies of other children are buried in an unmarked
grave nearby. Ahousat Coun. Angus Campbell says it's nonsense: "People
would know if it was there."

It goes on and on like this, but if you persist in pointing out the
spectacular unlikelihood that any of Annett's stories are true, you will
almost certainly find yourself accused of "smearing" him. That's what
happens if you're white, anyway. If you're aboriginal, you may find
yourself called a "police informant" or a "provocateur," or you'll be
accused of having been a "collaborator and abuser" during your time in
residential school. Annett has levelled just these accusations against his
detractors.

He has accused them as well of complicity in "a criminal conspiracy to
perpetrate and conceal acts of war, genocide, murder, ethnic cleansing,
slave labour, sterilization, land theft, pedophilia" and other such crimes,
and accused of conspiring to assault Annett, defraud him, and defame him in
order to conceal those crimes.

Among those individuals who stand accused of these things are several
Canadian journalists, judges, and corporate executives, former prime
minister Jean Chretien, the RCMP, the United Church of Canada, former
United Nations' Human Rights Commission chair Mary Robinson, former New
Democratic Party cabinet minister John Cashore, and the Nuu-chah-nuulth
Tribal Council. Even Annett's ex-wife has been implicated.

Paranoid accounts?

Everybody's out to get him. His supporters die mysteriously, there are
shadowy stalkers, night-time visits from people who dump dead deer on his
porch, and a "goon squad" run by the federal government. Mysterious people
severed the brake lines on Annett's car, twice. Bureaucrats with the
Insurance Corporation of British Columbia levy suspiciously high fines when
Annett gets into car accidents. Even corrupt tax collectors from the Canada
Revenue Agency are in on it. Believe it if you like. But the truth of all
this actually matters.

It matters to me because I can count several old friends and colleagues
among the people who show up as villains, collaborators and stooges in
Annett's conspiracy, and I know a thing or two about Annett from when we
were both young socialists, back in the 1970s.

It's personal because as a young reporter, I covered trials of pedophile
priests. I came to know their victims as friends. I also came to know brave
and kind clergymen who taught in residential schools, and I co-authored a
book about residential schools with the former inmates of St. Mary's
Mission.

One does not need to exaggerate or embellish anything about what happened
in those places.

The terrible reality

It has lately become routine to hear Annett defended along the lines of,
well, he may be wrong about some things, but at least he is bringing this
terrible history into the light. Or he is forcing us to confront a
"Canadian holocaust" that the news media in this country finds too hot to
handle.

This is not true, either. You could fill a steamer trunk with clippings of
articles about Indian residential schools that have appeared in Canadian
newspapers in recent years. There have been stories about the chronic
sexual abuse in the schools. There have been reports from criminal trials.
There have full accounts of the policies and laws and regulations that were
intended to employ the schools in a project of churning out obedient
regiments of brown-skinned white people.

There have been feature treatments of the schools' degeneration into
child-labour camps, and the part the schools played in reducing once-proud
nations to broken remnants. And there have been stories about the heroic
efforts First Nations' leaders have made to force the churches and the
federal government to squarely face all that shame.

There were front-page stories a century ago, too. In 1897, senior Indian
Affairs officials started blowing the whistle on the cavernous,
shoddily-built, creaking institutions, pointing out that you couldn't have
built more efficient incubation vectors for contagious disease, and for
mass death, if you tried.

Back then, P.H. Bryce, the Indian department's chief medical officer,
conducted a study of 1,500 children interned in 15 different Indian
residential schools across Canada. He found that one in four of the
children never made it out alive. A separate study of the Kuper Island
school found that four of every 10 children sent there over a 25-year
period never survived to graduate.

This is sufficiently damning. It is not necessary to assert, as Annett
does, that infectious diseases were deliberately employed as part of a plot
to "cull" Canada's aboriginal population. Everybody knows what happened. It
is no secret, and is not even a secret that there are mass graves.

This is not a revelation.

From the late 18th century until well into the 20th century, wave after
wave of epidemic diseases rolled through Indian villages across the
Canadian prairies. The sicknesses swept over the mountains, down through
all the valleys of the western slopes, up and down the West Coast, and up
and back again.

At the time of the first smallpox epidemic, almost a third of the
aboriginal people in what is now Canada lived in the tribal territories
that came to be called British Columbia. Then there was smallpox, measles,
chickenpox, diphtheria, influenza, mumps, tuberculosis, and typhoid. By the
1950s, the countryside was a vast, forested necropolis.

This is not a hidden history.

A landscape of tombs

This history lives on in the epics handed down in the oral literature of
the aboriginal peoples, and in the horrific first-hand accounts of settlers
and missionaries. It survives in fur trade journals, colonial
correspondence, newspaper accounts, hospital records, Indian residential
school studies, and sometimes in the very shape of the land itself.

There is hardly a cove or a bay in the 1,500 sea miles between Victoria and
Gingolx where you can put a shovel in the ground without unearthing human
bones. In the interior, anyone who has spent any time traversing the
territories of the Stlatlimx, the N'lakapamux, the In-Shuck-ch or the
Secwepemc will have noticed the tumuli, the overgrown burial places, the
forlorn little cemeteries. And you will hear the stories from the people
themselves.

You don't even have to leave town. In almost all the reserve villages
remaining around Vancouver and Victoria, you will see that beside the old
churches, there are plots filled with simple wooden crosses, or sometimes
just mounds, where crosses may once have been. Now and then you will even
come across rusted and gnarled pieces of iron sticking up out of the
ground, from what's left of the graceful, wrought iron crosses of the
Oblates of Mary Immaculate.

These graves come from the times when the sick died so quickly and in such
numbers that it's a wonder the few survivors could bring themselves to bury
the dead at all.

Indian country, as we used to call it, is a vast landscape of tombs. And
the dead are still there, among and between the houses of reborn, thriving
villages, and among and between the crumbling ruins of mission chapels,
church-run tuberculosis hospitals, dormitories, and residential schools.

After all this suffering, the very least we owe the dead, and the living,
is the truth.

Related Tyee stories:

* Residential School Survivors: Justice Frustrated (series)

* Mothers of a Native Hell
Reviewed: Good Intentions Gone Awry: Emma Crosby and the Methodist
Mission on the Northwest Coast

* Reconciling with First Nations (series)
How the 'New Relationship' is faring in the Fraser Valley.

Widely-published, Victoria-based writer Terry Glavin contributes this
occasional column, Dissent, to The Tyee. His most recent book is Waiting
for the Macaws and Other Stories from the Age of Extinctions (Penguin).