Brothers Elliot and Larry Jr. were shot, returning home from "Save Tookie Williams" rally in San Quentin, on Saturday 11-19-05

Sheriff's deputies found Elliot Noble , 20, of Oakland, fatally shot in a vehicle at the side of a road before noon, Contra Costa Sheriff's spokesman Jimmy Lee said.

The second victim, his 22-year-old brother, was taken by helicopter to John Muir Medical Center in Walnut Creek, where he remains in critical condition. Police have no suspects.

Venus Noble, their Mom, said she heard they might have been going to a music studio in Richmond. Sister Venus has worked for years against police brutality, to bring attention and to try to find ways to end the violence in Oakland's African-American communities. But even she could not shield her sons. 6 years ago, Venus Noble watched her nephew Chance Grundy die after he was shot and killed in West Oakland.

On 6-10-03, Elliot had been savagely assaulted by Oakland Police Officers while videotaping the police beating of his young friend Michael Henry. Pictures taken by Elliot were published by Indymedia and the SF Bayview Nationsl Black Newspaper.