I agree with you ardgowan. That episode in Jacobite history is over and no need to re-kindle or open wounds that are healing.I have had correspondence with GC...
Jared this is no vendetta and yes it has everything to do with modern Jacobitism. Remember this is the man who shouted fraud at Michael Stewart /Lafosse and...
I have not seen the DVD in question thus I will not comment on it. The problem with many of the programs DVD's etc., presented about Events Scottish history...
ScotHeritage@...
Sep 1, 2006 1:05 pm
5684
Malcolm, I AM contentious, provocative and express my convictions with a certain verve. However, it is not in my character to be discourteous towards the...
I am largely in agreement with Alan. I am writing this post from Bulgaria, where the Tsar Simeon II (I have been corrected by Bulgarian sister-in-law for...
One can never forget national pride in these situations. Charles I did... Jud Cole ... with a ... towards ... yours, I am ... need for a ... Constantinopolitan...
... with a ... towards ... Whatever your intentions, it was more than a trifle unbalanced to decry the lack of Jacobite leadership among members of the Church...
Is any member of the Jacobite Group able to enlighten me, as to who exactly was Melville Amadeus Henry Douglas Heddle de La Caillemotte de Massue de Ruvigny,...
... Melville the genealogist was descended from Pierre David de Massue de Ruvigny, a nephew of Henri, called "Earl of Galway" (according to the "Dictionary of...
The symbol of one's national pride is one's legitimate sovereign, one's True King. This is an anthropological principle of catholic application since God...
... From: Noel S. McFerran To: Jacobite@yahoogroups.com Sent: Monday, September 04, 2006 6:03 AM Subject: Re: [Jacobite] "The 9th Marquis of Ruvigny and...
As I wrote, "If I am understood, good. If not, the divergence in criteria of collocutors may create a problem for fruitful dialogue". ... discourteous ... I am...
Thank you, Noel and Keith, for the information and for confirming what I rather suspected. About his prowess as a genealogist, no-one can cast aspersions, but,...
Well and good if you're folowing that church. For many Scots in the 1630's, who had rejected, by in large, both the Roman Catholic and Episcopal forms of...
That sounds more like a theological principle than an anthropological one. Assuming that one's own beliefs are universal law can get one into a lot of trouble....
This reflects the problem with identifying Jacobitism with Romanism. And frankly, it plays into the ugliest contentions of the usurpers - viz. that James's...
I have nothing further to add, except - uncompromisingly - GOD SAVE THE KING! ... Romanism. ... usurpers - ... did ... consideration. ... nor ... to ... Making...
Well said ! You missed out Charles III who was, of course, an Anglican convert, until it suited him financially and socially to bend his knee to the Vatican. S...
Every time someone opens the Yahoo Jacobite group page, "Jacobite - Jacobitism Yesterday and Today", he/she will see besides the small portrait of King James...
Charles III apparently wasn't an Anglican for very long, since he was born and raised a Catholic and returned to the Catholic Church. Did it perhaps suit him...
ardgowan
ardgowan@...
Sep 9, 2006 3:59 am
5701
In the context, I think it is apparent I was referring to Chas 3d. I'm not sure what "brain fart" moved me to write IV vice III. ... convert, until it suited...
A very good point though an argument could be made that the reason James II gave Anglicanism more respect than Church of England-following rulers did to...
I am a Catholic and have been for 25 years. I've been a Jacobite for almost 50! "Nuff said? -- Jovan-Marya Weismiller, T.O.Carm. Read The New Crusade at...
Had King Charles II had a legitimate heir, male or female, by his Consort, Queen Catherine of Braganza, which heir, in the normal course of events, would have...
If I remember, he declared himself an Anglican significantly after the '45 - perhaps not until his brother became a cardinal. Purely political of course, and...
Bill.run, I have not overlooked your posting on August 24, with your interesting observations, which deserve an answer. It is on the way... Rather than reply...
If Charles II had left legitimate Anglican children there would be no jacobites - at least under that name - because James would not have been King to be...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
