--- In Fabric-of-Reality@yahoogroups.com, "tomegalovlito" <tomegalovlito@...>
wrote:
>
>
>
> --- In Fabric-of-Reality@yahoogroups.com, "Peter D" <peterdjones@> wrote:
> >
> >
> >
> > --- In Fabric-of-Reality@yahoogroups.com, "tomegalovlito" <tomegalovlito@>
wrote:
> >
> > > But if no government would do it, then it can't happen.
> >
> > Some political parties are in favour of the idea, so it could happen.
> >
>
> Who's in favour of abolishing wages and replacing them with shares?
>
Are there any parallels between the culture/society relevant findings of this philosophy and the findings of cultural marxism? "Cultural Marxism is a term...
... Yes and no. Deutsch does not acknowledge conflicts of interest and therefore considers the evolution of ideas largely independent of material factors. The...
... Correct. ... Well, FWIW that's not quite accurate, but it'll do for the issue you're addressing in this post. ... Good heavens, no! See below. ... Quite...
... Have I blundered? I must have. As I said before, I'm not a very capable marxist. I'm not sufficiently educated, in marxism or in general political...
... Speaking in the way other people speak facilitates communication, so people on some level think it suits them to copy and use language structure. Maybe...
... What does "on some level think X" mean? Is it compatible with "emphatically deny knowledge of X if asked; are unable to detect any trace of X in their...
... It means that they probably won't realise it until it's pointed out to them. ... Or maybe learning how to speak properly is a gradual process interspersed...
... I don't see how material changes can be a sufficient causes of such a change. In any case, the worker/capitalist distinction can disappear just as quickly;...
... Material changes not only directly lead to ideas, but they also affect the power of certain groups who spread ideas. ... Or they could declare a sudden...
... If material changes lead directly to ideas that means everybody who observes material stuff gets the same idea, the idea follows from the observations -...
... Trivial theories, as well as ideas which are not theories, are more or less the same for people who get the same input. But yeah, that's just about the...
... Any marxist account of history explains it in terms of material causes. ... It's not evasion. It's something that wouldn't happen because of the nature of...
... So you are proving Marxism to be correct by assuming the correctness of Marxism? ... It evasion because it is beside the point. It may be the case that no...
... No, I just suck at coming up with good concrete examples so I gave a general answer. ... But if no government would do it, then it can't happen....
... You mean giving them some shares on top of their regular salary? They already do that in Japan. It doesn't change a thing. The workers just get a bit of...
Offline 
Send Email